News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Internet Should Be a Public Good by tptacek on Wednesday August 31, 2016 @02:19PM (#12400321)
I'm sure if the government had retained full control of the Internet as a regulated public utility, the US would have the finest Department of Streaming Video in the world.
Re:The Internet Should Be a Public Good by dtornabene on Wednesday August 31, 2016 @04:14PM (#12401150)
Why is this any different than the previous upthread comments you called "rude" and labeled with Forum Psych 101 : Fallacy Section. Its kind of ugly, honestly. I say this as someone who has actually taken the time to email you before, thanking you for calling out racism.
Re:The Internet Should Be a Public Good by tptacek on Wednesday August 31, 2016 @04:22PM (#12401199)
As I said elsewhere: mine is a substantive dismissal, and theirs is an ad hominem argument directed at a misapprehension about my politics. If you disagree with my argument, disagree with it.
Re:The Internet Should Be a Public Good by borkborkbork on Wednesday August 31, 2016 @02:30PM (#12400400)
The attitude that leads to you ridicule government provided services is exactly why I made my previous comment about your obvious political bias. It wasn't any more rude than the sarcasm that you're exhibiting here.

Ask the Brits about the NHS.

Re:The Internet Should Be a Public Good by tptacek on Wednesday August 31, 2016 @02:32PM (#12400408)
One difference between my comment and yours is that you were in fact incorrect about my political inclinations, but I am not in fact wrong about the service model of a regulated public Internet.

You're doing the same thing by asking me to litigate the NHS: presuming that I'm opposed to all government services and all regulations. I won't play that game: you are out of bounds by personalizing this, and asking me to pass a purity test to continue arguing with you isn't reasonable.

Argue better.

Re:The Internet Should Be a Public Good by borkborkbork on Wednesday August 31, 2016 @02:41PM (#12400469)
I haven't asked you to do anything of the sort. I point out the NHS because I want you to explain why the internet is fundamentally different. You've done an excellent job explaining how the existing internet emerged. You've done nothing to discredit my actual argument.