News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Theranos Halts New Zika Test After FDA Inspection by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday August 31, 2016 @10:38AM (#12398616)
And all of the responses and negativity skate around the positive results and the tragic loss of an effective diagnostic procedure. Because 'rules'.

The oversight (potentially risking folks safety by not doing a finger stick with the right paperwork?) has nothing to do with the actual medical test nor does it compromise the results. Yet everybody is fine with punishing an unpopular company because of yes technicalities. While public safety and the lives of unborn children are at serious risk.

I don't get the nerd mentality sometimes. Common sense flies right out the window.

Re:Theranos Halts New Zika Test After FDA Inspection by enzamatic on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @12:16PM (#12444599)
There are other companies who followed the rules and do have a successful test for Zika. A company with Theranos history should have been following the rules, knowing they had already screwed up. They're currently, unless their appeal succeeds, going to be barred from performing ANY testing for 2 years. Actually the fact that they are under appeal makes failure to follow procedures even more astounding.

The question is, why is this bar a problem for them and not others? Inability to follow a basic protocol is a good sign of their incompetence with regard to deeper issues I suspect.

Re:Theranos Halts New Zika Test After FDA Inspection by apathy on Thursday September 01, 2016 @11:38PM (#12410672)
Thalidomide was also banned in the US "because rules".

Common sense in medicine prioritizes doing no harm.

I can provide other notable examples if need be. The bottom line is that all parties need to be confident that the expected benefit of a test or procedure outweighs any expected potential harms. Having multiple layers or peer review is one way to ensure this.

I work on clinical trials of "black label" (potentially lethal) agents in patients that typically have no other options. Our pages can be 70-100 pages and we are doing this in our "spare" time (Ha! Ha!). I don't think it's unreasonable for a massively capitalized private company to produce documentation at least up to this standard.

It really isn't much to ask, especially for an existential venture like this (something -- anything! -- trustworthy to recover the tremendous amount of credibility they've lost.)

Other companies had no problem writing a suitable protocol. Why should peoples' safety be compromised just so that an untrustworthy company can enter the market?

Re:Theranos Halts New Zika Test After FDA Inspection by JoeAltmaier on Friday September 02, 2016 @08:12PM (#12417076)
We're talking a finger stick here. And a devastating illness that is poised to become a worldwide epidemic.
Re:Theranos Halts New Zika Test After FDA Inspection by apathy on Friday September 02, 2016 @09:28PM (#12417271)
For which other diagnostics exist from companies that somehow managed to submit a proper protocol.

Unlike Zika tests, it is extremely rare for patients in the trials I design to have any alternatives. Also unlike Zika, the standard of care in the diseases I work on yields less than 25% 5-year survival.

Not birth defects (horrific though they may be) but death from organ failure and infection. Nearly all of the compounds are known or potential teratogens. No alternative sources for most of the drugs. Still need an IRB.

You say, "oh it's just a finger stick!" To which I must say, have you looked at the number of physicians and nurses who got Hep C or HIV from an errant finger stick in the hospital?!

Re:Theranos Halts New Zika Test After FDA Inspection by JoeAltmaier on Thursday September 08, 2016 @09:09AM (#12452594)
And I come back again with "Mothers and babies and a worldwide epidemic"
Re:Theranos Halts New Zika Test After FDA Inspection by seesomesense on Thursday September 01, 2016 @12:00AM (#12403017)
"tragic loss of an effective diagnostic procedure"

Theranos' last attempt at an effective diagnostic test for the effects of warfarin caused at least one stroke in a patient due to inaccurate results.

Both false positive and false negative Zika virus tests would have equally undesirable ramifications.

How many women would you like to have Theranos harm with their implementations that have been well documented to be appalling ?