Re:The Plan to Save a Life by Head Transplant
by SamReidHughes on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @02:14PM
(#12392479)
Fortunately we all understood this to be in the context of performing a medical operation.
Re:The Plan to Save a Life by Head Transplant
by pmoriarty on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @02:19PM
(#12392518)
I'm not sure I understand what you're getting at. Are you saying that usefulness trumps ethics in medicine but not in warfare? If so, why do you think that?
Re:The Plan to Save a Life by Head Transplant
by Gracana on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @02:28PM
(#12392612)
Of course it doesn't "trump ethics." In the context of a hand transplant, the likelihood of the procedure resulting in a useful hand is a large part of deciding whether or not it's ethical. The likelihood of improved quality of life is weighed against the likelihood of pain and complications.
Re:The Plan to Save a Life by Head Transplant
by maxerickson on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @02:23PM
(#12392555)
My meaning was that hand transplants would (probably) be unethical if the result provided no function. The technique is good enough that the benefits outweigh the costs.
Obviously they must also consider the other aspects of it ethical.
Re:The Plan to Save a Life by Head Transplant
by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @04:27PM
(#12393574)
> "the doctors apparently believe them to be useful enough to be ethical"
> I don't think ethics works that way.
I'm pretty sure that they do.
> Just because something is very useful doesn't necessarily mean that it's ethical.
OTOH, for lots of things (and surgical operations with inherent risks are pretty solidly on this list) utility is certainly relevant to (and a certain level, a prerequisite for) an action to be ethical, even if it is not sufficient alone to determine that the action is ethical.
I don't think ethics works that way. Just because something is very useful doesn't necessarily mean that it's ethical.
Nuclear weapons are a case in point. Few will deny that they're very useful and effective weapons, but many believe their use to be unethical, no matter how useful they are.
Chemical and biological weapons, and cluster bombs are other similar examples.