It would be more accurate to say that universities are exploitative than that the existence of a self-reproducing class of professional scientists is irrational.
>But perhaps the best way to get answers is to talk to the parents of college students, the ones footing the bill. Ask whether they’d rather pay that ballooning college tuition for lazy rivers on campus, for fruit baskets and housekeepers for executive staff, and for other rising non-classroom costs; or for more top PhD talent, smaller classrooms, more one-on-one attention from faculty, more independent studies and research opportunities with faculty, and a stable faculty who won’t have to leave halfway through their student’s college career. Then you’ll get a sense of the real, unmet demand for PhDs, and the irrationality of a market that isn’t delivering.
My willpower is wearing down, considering the effort it takes to achieve a full Coq development of something serious like that.
I also have a friend who's trying to Solve Programming Languages by building a dependently-typed systems programming language with modules and type-classes and such, so I can pass him the code and proofs if I really so burningly desire to see my work "ship" somewhere, somehow.
Smart. Might work out.
" building a dependently-typed systems programming language"
I've seen a few of those: ATS, Idris, Bedrock in a way. Has your friend published any work showing off his? Or is it still in pre-alpha development?
I know at least 3 people that knowingly got PHDs in majors that will not amount to any sort of high-paying job. They chose to do this and it's not really the job of the university to determine the market value of their degrees.