Re:Cautionary Tales from Brexit, Grexit and U.S Budget Battles
by Hermel on Monday August 29, 2016 @04:18PM
(#12384955)
The question is: is the EU the symptom or the cause of peace in Europe? According to the Nobel price committee, the EU is the cause. But I have some doubts... a badly governed EU could even spark nationalist resentments instead of containing it.
Re:Cautionary Tales from Brexit, Grexit and U.S Budget Battles
by mikeash on Monday August 29, 2016 @04:24PM
(#12385002)
Certainly, it's a big question that nobody can answer for sure. My point is mainly that saying people have fought and died for this stuff throughout history isn't really an argument against disaster after the fall of the EU.
Re:Cautionary Tales from Brexit, Grexit and U.S Budget Battles
by DicksenZuider on Monday August 29, 2016 @04:27PM
(#12385026)
The American/Allied victory in World War II is the responsible for most of the relatively peaceful world situation. A cooperating West Europe resulted from this.
Re:Cautionary Tales from Brexit, Grexit and U.S Budget Battles
by AnimalMuppet on Monday August 29, 2016 @05:00PM
(#12385269)
And a cooperating West Europe existed for years before the EU. Ascribing the peace to the EU seems somewhat revisionist.
Re:Cautionary Tales from Brexit, Grexit and U.S Budget Battles
by mikeash on Monday August 29, 2016 @05:12PM
(#12385386)
The various precursor institutions to the EU go back to 1952.
Re:Cautionary Tales from Brexit, Grexit and U.S Budget Battles
by AnimalMuppet on Monday August 29, 2016 @05:29PM
(#12385522)
Sure, but nobody's crediting the six-member European Coal and Steel Community with being the source of European peace.
Re:Cautionary Tales from Brexit, Grexit and U.S Budget Battles
by cloakandswagger on Monday August 29, 2016 @04:11PM
(#12384911)
Look at what's happened to Greece under ECB control. Do you really think a monetary union like the EU will prevent war? If anything it encourages it; imagine having your country's economy ravaged by policy set by unelected officials a thousand miles away.
Re:Cautionary Tales from Brexit, Grexit and U.S Budget Battles
by tomp on Monday August 29, 2016 @04:29PM
(#12385047)
Personally, I believe that the Erasmus programme (the EU+ student exchange programme), which is, admittedly, a part of EU, has done much more for preserving future peace in Europe than all the rest of EU institutions combined.
Of course, maybe it won't happen that way. But pointing out that people have gone to war over this stuff throughout history is not really helping.