Re:What is a viable alternative to basic income?
by Grishnakh on Tuesday August 30, 2016 @12:23PM
(#12391501)
There's absolutely no economic rationale for space travel and colonization. If you have automation doing all the lower-end jobs, and no way of transitioning society past the current system where you have to work to support yourself, it's very simple: all these extra people will have to be eliminated. So we have 3 choices: 1) start up death camps and start transporting unemployed people to them for disposal, 2) undergo a violent economic collapse with food riots, uncontrolled crime, etc., or 3) institute a UBI. Only one of these is humane and rational.
Take a look at http://www.mckinsey.com/global-themes/employment-and-growth/..., which has this byline (June 2012): Strains on the global labor force are becoming painfully evident. Market forces will fail to resolve demand and supply imbalances for tens of millions of skilled and unskilled workers.
As automation becomes ever more adaptive and versatile, it will be interesting to see in what ways human employment may somehow remain economically of interest. But right now the labor force participation trends downward, and the only way that could be good is if the non-participation people are having healthfully happy lifestyles - perhaps as retirees or married to well-to-do spouses.
But if the social order of things is changing such that the prospect of gainful employment becomes less tenable for most, here's to hoping that a better world may yet emerge with minimal strife. Otherwise, it's all too easy to imagine us collectively squabble and fret over moral hazards, free-loaders, and property rights (including the intellectual kind), and that the crisis must first reach a breaking point before any material changes can happen.
If UBI is a non-starter, I've got no ideas other than for maybe getting serious about space travel and colonization.