Re:The Concept of ‘Cat Face’
by derefr on Sunday August 28, 2016 @02:09PM
(#12377625)
It doesn't seem all that amazing to me.
Humans have to be trained to perceive the differences in complex streams of information; by default, they just perceive the low-level features—a "wall of noise."
Machine-learning algorithms, meanwhile, can use general techniques to notice information-theoretic properties of various pieces of data. Effectively, computers can "do statistical aggregation" about as effortlessly as humans "do hierarchical knowledge representation."
And, in an information-theoretic sense, the different "trends" throughout the history of music look different under statistical analysis. They're complex in different ways; they have different "lumps"; different aspects of them can or cannot be compressed together as redundancies.
If you would like to see this for yourself, simply feed a raw melodic note-structure (not embedded in XML or anything) to any modern dumb compression algorithm, and then look at the result in a hex editor, while also having the source still open. You should quickly be able to recognize the "transformational signature" that characterizes something like a chaconne, vs. something like a sonata.
Humans have to be trained to perceive the differences in complex streams of information; by default, they just perceive the low-level features—a "wall of noise."
Machine-learning algorithms, meanwhile, can use general techniques to notice information-theoretic properties of various pieces of data. Effectively, computers can "do statistical aggregation" about as effortlessly as humans "do hierarchical knowledge representation."
And, in an information-theoretic sense, the different "trends" throughout the history of music look different under statistical analysis. They're complex in different ways; they have different "lumps"; different aspects of them can or cannot be compressed together as redundancies.
If you would like to see this for yourself, simply feed a raw melodic note-structure (not embedded in XML or anything) to any modern dumb compression algorithm, and then look at the result in a hex editor, while also having the source still open. You should quickly be able to recognize the "transformational signature" that characterizes something like a chaconne, vs. something like a sonata.