Speaking for myself, I'm a 2-3 cups a day on the weekdays kind of person (up until about 2-3pm at which point I cut myself off). But on weekends I often have none (just too lazy to make a cup), and I've never experienced any associated withdrawal symptoms.
At night, I can have a espresso, coffee, or caffeinated soda at 9pm and be ready to sleep at 11. I've stopped drinking it for weeks at a time before, with no difficulty doing so. All of the stories about caffeine's extreme effects are completely alien to me; I've always considered it a fairly gentle substance.
The half-life of caffeine definitely has a lot of individual variability (3-7 hours is apparently the reference range, but I think the overall observed range is wider with e.g. other drugs or liver dysfunction). I'm not sure whether a longer or shorter half-life would be more conducive to addiction.
A person may have low tolerance/high sensitivity (due to fewer adenosine receptors) but metabolize quickly.
I actually find I have high sensitivity and metabolize slowly, which is why it's important I don't have coffee after mid-afternoon.
My bet is that long half-life/slow metabolism increases predilection for addiction (due to longer duration of exposure), but that's just a guess.
I am now at week two in the process of quitting, because I'm getting increasingly concerned about being in the withdrawal zone as well as being "fully caffeinated". The first week was much worse than the second one. Hopefully I get back to my old self soon.
The funny thing is how hard it is to avoid caffeine after you quit. In the fast food restaurant there are almost no decaf diet drinks. So do you want caffeine or diabetes?
I am very curious about this topic because I am considering dropping caffeine, but then again I have read so much scientific literature about coffee's antioxidant properties, and caffeine being good for memory, etc, plus I love the taste of coffee, and always prefer to drink it black (I can just eat coffee beans)
I'd been drinking that much coffee for maybe ten years and I think my sleep quality had been going downhill for a long time. I'd get to sleep without a problem, but woke up late, always felt tired and hated mornings. I'm now a morning person.
I'm glad it was so easy to kick. Thinking back at how I felt and for how long leaves me with a sense of loss of self.