Re:In Mathematics, Mistakes Aren’t What They Used to Be (2015)
by kxyvr on Saturday August 27, 2016 @04:29PM
(#12374025)
That'd be great, but I think the hard part about sharing representations is that many of the proof tools are based on different underlying type theories, which make it hard to go back and forth. For example Coq is based on the calculus of inductive constructions whereas Isabelle is based on HOL. Though, I'm guessing it's possible once a type scheme is fixed. Just poking around briefly, here's an SO question and answer on some of the differences between CIC and HOL (https://stackoverflow.com/questions/30152139/what-are-the-st...)
Tools like coq are great, but difficult to use (even as a programmer used to languages like Haskell) and they don't have a large set of existing proofs to work off of.
My opinion is that we need a good intermediate representation for proof tools (to share results; each new tool now needs a huge base built up to start being useful) and simpler tools to work with. It would be an enormous benefit to mathematicians and the world at large.