If we're not omniscient, the best we can do is put people in bins: "99% of the people in this bin will pay back their debt in full ...but only 65% of the people in this bin will pay their debt in full".
So...what do we do with people who are in the 65% bin?
Do we cut off ALL of them from access to credit?
Or do we give them access to credit, but at higher interest rates?
Personally, I don't think that someone X who shares demographic traits with someone else Y who will not pay his debt should be punished by lack of access to credit.
(a) We don't need to be omniscient to know that giving a no-doc zero-down mortgage to someone making $30k a year is a bad plan, or that it makes no fiscal sense to let people take out HELOCs on their houses that can only be paid back if the house appreciates 5+N% year over year.
(b) In the real world outside this message board, lenders are actually employing intelligence in the exact opposite direction, optimizing lending to capture people who will pay more in interest and penalties than they will in principal.
Conversely, if you do give credit cards to just about anyone, then you shouldn't have sympathy for them if they borrow themselves into servitude.