Re:An undercover cop who abandoned the war on drugs
by logfromblammo on Friday August 26, 2016 @04:22PM
(#12369049)
Are we pretending that post hoc, ergo propter hoc is not a fallacy?
If a crime has multiple contributing factors, that does not necessarily make any of those factors a crime in itself.
One might as well say that because murder with a firearm is a crime, that possession of bullets should also be considered criminal.
It is perfectly reasonable to say that crimes may be related to non-crimes. But in our system, the crime should be defined by objective criteria, or elements, such that a judge and jury can determine whether they exist or not based on evidence and testimony.
And while is it possible to define a crime without a victim's complaint as an element, my own opinion is that such laws should be relatively rare, or severely limited in their application and scope.
If a crime has multiple contributing factors, that does not necessarily make any of those factors a crime in itself.
One might as well say that because murder with a firearm is a crime, that possession of bullets should also be considered criminal.
It is perfectly reasonable to say that crimes may be related to non-crimes. But in our system, the crime should be defined by objective criteria, or elements, such that a judge and jury can determine whether they exist or not based on evidence and testimony.
And while is it possible to define a crime without a victim's complaint as an element, my own opinion is that such laws should be relatively rare, or severely limited in their application and scope.