> no conclusions should be drawn from a single study period
I didn't see the point in pointing out the obvious - I thought that's as annoying as on reddit's /r/science the inevitable single-sentence comment "correlation is not causation" for no reason whatsoever (i.e. when nobody made that claim). I pointed out the age threshold because there was a comment (of only 6 or 7 total at that point) that attempted to draw the conclusion that older people are doing worse.The paper more or less confirms from the cognitive domain, that we are working to much. Upto 25 hours are the best. This interestingly coincides with claims from others, eg. UBI folks, to work less for increased productivity. Seems we are getting more and more factual prove that eg. redistribution of wealth should be done not by increasing taxes but by getting more people into the workforce in exchange of others working less (and earning less).
> From what do you come to the conclusion that older people are doing worse?
What on earth are you asking me??? I don't! Please actually read what people write before clicking on "Reply"!{{citation needed}}
The article crisply called out differences between men and women, on page 13.
If your argument is that these differences are not significant, could you point to the part of the paper that justifies that statement?
"Interestingly, there is no statistical difference in the effects of working hours on cognitive functioning between men and women."
"However, we find that there is no statistically significant gender difference in the effects of working hours on cognitive functioning. "
> ...they are saying gender difference results were not statistically significant -
> I don't understand why even report them then ?
Because reporting a negative find is information too.What is the difference between not knowing and knowing there is nothing? Don't tell me there is none... :)
Yes, 10% is "significant" in the sense that it would be enough for people to care about.
The paper is saying that the sample size is too small to have any confidence that you'd still have a difference (or that the difference wouldn't go in the other direction) if you took a different sample of the population.
But you are right it makes more sense that they are saying gender difference results were not statistically significant - I don't understand why even report them then ?
Important detail: They only looked at people 40 or older, so no conclusions should be attempted based on this paper alone about differences between older and younger groups (above/below 40). Looking at their tables at the end of the paper I also didn't see any stratification by age within the sampled group, they only listed the sample size for three (15 years wide) age groups (Table II).