News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by mikeash on Thursday August 25, 2016 @02:42PM (#12361357)
I can't decide whether or not I'm playing devil's advocate with this question. In any case, please don't take it too seriously, but I think it might be interesting.

Why did you not include a trigger warning about the discussion of rape in your comment?

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by zyxley on Thursday August 25, 2016 @02:51PM (#12361431)
"Mention of rape" and "discussion of rape in enough detail to cause discomfort" are not the same thing.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by mikeash on Thursday August 25, 2016 @02:56PM (#12361479)
I'm sure we can find someone who is uncomfortable at the mere mention of the word. Not that we should necessarily accommodate such extremes, but how do you decide where to draw the line?
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by PhasmaFelis on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:30PM (#12361770)
You work together to find a reasonable balance between accommodating the most common and severe trauma triggers without shutting down general discussion.

For example, there are people who were raped by a man with a deep voice and are triggered by men with deep voices. That's a really shitty situation to be in, but it's unreasonably onerous to expect deep-voiced men to warn everyone in the vicinity (perhaps with a sign) before speaking, especially since there are very few people with that particular trigger. Asking people to give a warning before they intend to discuss rape in detail is not onerous, and it helps a rather larger number of people.

Edit: I'd really like to know why this is getting downvoted.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by ItsDeathball on Thursday August 25, 2016 @05:07PM (#12362519)
I actually know someone who just shuts down and freezes for a few minutes at the mere mention of the word "rape". This person has made their discomfort known to their friends and requested the word be avoided in conversation, which is an easy enough request to comply with out of courtesy.

Note that this is a group of people drawn from 4chan and adjacent communities whose primary socialization is voip and online games, all areas known for a "challenging" discussion environment. The line seems to be, in this case, that one can reasonably expect to carve out a "safe space" among family and friends, but not total strangers.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by jpfed on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:09PM (#12361594)
If we try to have a culture that considers trigger warnings a courtesy worth extending, rather than having a policy saying yes/no, then the question of where the line should be drawn can be answered by each instructor as they see fit.

It's likely that a few obviously triggering things can be labelled as such and good can be derived from that even if we can't or shouldn't label everything.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by qntty on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:05PM (#12361562)
You guess and invite people to correct you if you're wrong? How is anything that requires judgement decided? Eventually there will be an accepted norm but at the beginning there never is.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by deong on Thursday August 25, 2016 @04:23PM (#12362188)
That's a nice solution if everything is more or less working properly. The problem is, "What do you do when they tell you you're wrong about everything?"

One of the links in the article was to an article by a law professor talking about the difficulty of teaching rape and sexual assault law. The point being made there was that the entire subject has become off-limits -- literally, a large number of her colleagues had simply elected not to teach it anymore.

If your complaint is that, today, students are demanding an abuse of the notion of trigger warnings and safe spaces to effectively prevent exposure to potentially upsetting discussions, and that we are harming the long-term development of students by doing so, then by definition, you believe the corrections you'd get would essentially take the form "bring back all the trigger warnings we had when you started this process".

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by coddingtonbear on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:11PM (#12361615)
That might be true, but there are a variety of cases where we've decided to stop using a word in general in order to avoid causing undue distress; "slave" (i/r/t "master" and "slave") in a computing context is now generally always phrased in another way, for example.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by Nadya on Thursday August 25, 2016 @04:25PM (#12362203)
That's mostly self-contained on Github. Where busybodies have little else to do but open issues on projects in the name of social justice without ever contributing to the project itself in a meaningful manner. See: /r/gitinaction

The word "master" was also under fire not too long ago. They replaced it with "head". I'm honestly surprised a certain political group haven't jumped at the opportunity to get "head" replaced due to being too phalic.

[0] http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3464182/Harvard-Univ...

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by warkdarrior on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:46PM (#12361914)
> "slave" (i/r/t "master" and "slave") in a computing context is now generally always phrased in another way, for example

I need to educate myself. What do people use instead of "slave device" in computing?

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by galdosdi on Thursday August 25, 2016 @04:47PM (#12362369)
Databases have been using master/replica lately, which, fortuitously is (usually) actually slightly more precise anyway, and so is strictly better in every way
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by barsonme on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:57PM (#12361992)
The projects I've seen have gone with "leader/follower" https://github.com/django/django/commit/8a95b4fca793eeb8adce...
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by kuschku on Thursday August 25, 2016 @05:39PM (#12362715)
So, the solution is to literally use Führer instead of Master?

That’s a great choice, not only reprinting tons of literature, changing tons of code, but also choosing a Nazi analogy instead!

Every word triggers someone, society can’t be expected to adapt to anyone.

And I’ll continue to use Master/Slave, and continue to support the Sinter Klaas and Zwarte Piet tradition in the Netherlands.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by mercer on Friday August 26, 2016 @05:54AM (#12365238)
No, it's literally to use 'leader'. Not a German word that has a rather specific meaning when used in languages outside of German (although I suppose it's at least somewhat loaded in Germany too).
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by kuschku on Friday August 26, 2016 @09:31AM (#12366056)
It’s severely loaded in German, and how’d you teach students about "leader/follower" without translating that part?

There’s something like other languages, which you translate to for documentation or teaching purposes, which means the German material will either have only this one in english (which leads to everyone immediately realizing why), or just using Führer.

That’s not in any way solving the issue.

For every word, there is a context in which it is offensive. Just stop caring about that, instead of trying to do the impossible for no benefit.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by Pete_D on Thursday August 25, 2016 @04:16PM (#12362138)
I can't remember which, but I saw one project change to "primary/secondary".
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by dri_ft on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:56PM (#12361982)
"Servant". I prefer "slave".
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by vidarh on Thursday August 25, 2016 @04:07PM (#12362059)
That just gives me an intense urge to use master/slave all over the place.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by tzs on Thursday August 25, 2016 @04:28PM (#12362216)
I've went the opposite direction. I now describe the organization of a typical plantation in mid-19th century America as being run by a white leader with black followers doing the work.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by masterleep on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:23PM (#12361716)
That's the kind of absurd oversensitivity that opponents of trigger warnings are against.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by philovivero on Thursday August 25, 2016 @09:34PM (#12363774)
Very much not generally nor always.

Source: I am a professional high-volume database guy doing this stuff since the mid 1990's and still deeply embedded with it now.

There are projects that have chosen other nouns, and they have ridden the wave of publicity around this, but by my estimation* more than 90% of database-related projects still use master/slave.

*as in I haven't done any formal record-keeping, nor will I.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by MichaelGG on Thursday August 25, 2016 @04:59PM (#12362461)
Citation? I remember someone going around with PRs to change things and being roundly laughed out.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by r_smart on Friday August 26, 2016 @11:34AM (#12366947)
At least in the world of electrical engineering, you are quite incorrect. There are masters and slaves all over the place around here.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by wflynny on Thursday August 25, 2016 @02:52PM (#12361449)
Mentioning the word rape is not a discussion of rape.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by basseq on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:02PM (#12361532)
The article links to another on teaching rape law to criminal-law students.[1] From that article:

  One teacher I know was recently asked by a student not 
  to use the word “violate” in class—as in “Does this 
  conduct violate the law?”—because the word was 
  triggering.
So in some cases, even mentioning the word is included in this issue.

[1] http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/trouble-teaching-rap...

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by PhasmaFelis on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:31PM (#12361790)
I would call that an unreasonable request. But that doesn't invalidate the existence of reasonable requests.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by basseq on Thursday August 25, 2016 @04:06PM (#12362050)
I would agree. (And was responding to the parent comment.) It begs two questions, though:

1. What's "reasonable"?

2. Does the meaning of "reasonable" change? (E.g., a criminal-law class vs. a computer science class) To me, this could be redefined as "topic appropriateness".

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by emblem21 on Thursday August 25, 2016 @06:04PM (#12362855)
1. If I started posting the N-word over and over again this very moment, you would instinctively consider that unreasonable, so let's stop pretending to not know the definitions of things.

2. You can't rigorously define the boundaries of context.

With those two axioms, we can conclude that the root of the matter, which protecting the feelings of children who have been catered to their whole lives, is not a path worthy of resource or virtue. These are the same overmedicated people who simulanteously hold the belief they are just specks of dust in the universe while screaming about the importance of their feelings. Too many TED talks, not enough TED debates.

They are of zero consequence when you account for these factors.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by PhasmaFelis on Thursday August 25, 2016 @06:48PM (#12363089)
I was with you on the first two points. I'm not sure how you got from there to the third.

> With those two axioms, we can conclude that the root of the matter, which protecting the feelings of children who have been catered to their whole lives, is not a path worthy of resource or virtue.

No, the root of the matter is protecting sexual assault victims with PTSD. Certainly some entitled children have tried to hijack that train for their own petty benefit, but we don't eliminate Medicaid just because Medicaid cheats exist. (Well, most of us don't.)

You're quite right that you can't rigorously define the values of context: something can only work with broad guidelines interpreted on a case-by-case basis. That does not mean that they're completely unaddressable and we shouldn't bother. People are not machines.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by emblem21 on Thursday August 25, 2016 @08:04PM (#12363416)
I never said the problem wasn't addressable. I said the types of people “safe spaces” are supposedly "protecting" are of zero consequence. As long as they are engulfed by their trauma, they are literally, of zero consequence. The problem of handling trauma is very addressable: Eliminate the safe space.

To elaborate, we have to talk about the nature of neurons and, specifically, neural plasticity.

Trauma is trauma (regardless of mass media campaigns to favor one type of trauma over another on a monthly basis) and neurons adapt accordingly. (Not always optimally in regards to personal development in an industrial context, mind you) Most importantly, they also heal accordingly. VR/AR experiments show the important of the visual cortex in rewiring the neural systems of paraplegics, allowing them to move their feet. This clearly shows the need of people to experience the world beyond what they have already modeled to be a reality to overcome massive trauma.

If people who have literally endured physical destruction of parts of the spinal column can utilize therapy to reprogram massive regions of the neurology to restore some physical functionality to a previously unrecoverable fate, I'm left with no choice but call into question the entire premise of "the safe space" and what function it is actually serving. (Other than unofficial voter turnout rallies)

Neurons are feisty things and to undermine their amazing abilities by claiming an individual's trauma is beyond neural plasticity is ultimately discrediting the fundamental humanness of the people you are aiming to protect. You are effectively saying "This victim is so broken and so subhuman, not even their neurons work anymore." In essence, you are the one saying people are machines because your altruism has concluded they are incapable of engaging in neural plasticity, and thus, must be denied sensory input via safe spaces to reflect that incapacitation.

Protecting the traumatized from what YOU think they should be protected from ultimately deprives them of the experiences and opportunities that neurons need to adapt to the trauma. No one heals in a jail cell of sensory denial, no matter how well-intentioned the warden. Thus, putting rigid borders on context will always fail, even if you are successful in the feat.

Have a little bit more faith that two billion years of biological evolution knows slightly more about itself than a few hundred thousand Xanga/LiveJournal ex-pats who are spending their 30s in one last angsty hurrah on Tumblr.

I realize this conclusion regarding the necessity of novel and unpredictable experiences to assist in trauma recovery contends against the widespread obsession of pathological altruism; the idea that those who mean well must do anything regardless of efficacy. This explains why Medicaid will always exist, no matter how many ill-willed scammers or high-power lobbyists game the system to their respective favors. Pathological altruism dictates that no cancer can ever be large enough, even as it devours the system whole. This just creates an ecosystem of competing parasites that undermines the legitimacy of that altruism via Poe's Law. Eventually, recruitment drives start to fail as essential outsiders and new blood no longer view your altruism as meaningful. Then it's off to the next monthly flavor of altruism, which is the same as the last one, all made up of the same previous players, but now with slick new branding to attract the freshly unaligned and uninitiated!

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by apricot on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:01PM (#12361526)
The use-mention distinction is a sensitive subject for me, so I would appreciate getting a warning next time you allude to it. Thanks!
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by rad88 on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:31PM (#12361785)
You're making fun of the sensitivities and stress experienced by some people after they are raped. Nice one.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by DickingAround on Thursday August 25, 2016 @02:53PM (#12361453)
(Not all that sure myself) Perhaps because it's difficult to simulate the brain of all the other readers and reasonably anticipate offense. Like I know rape happens and describing it in detail might be something that most people are asking for 'trigger warnings' about. But only because it's been talked about. I actually can't simulate the brain of a rape victim and anticipate such things independently.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by FT_intern on Thursday August 25, 2016 @02:55PM (#12361471)
When a trigger warning is announced, a triggering concept is mentioned. When a triggering concept is mentioned, people are triggered. Soon, people associate trigger warnings with the triggered symptoms.

We need a trigger warning about trigger warnings.