News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by dragonwriter on Thursday August 25, 2016 @02:41PM (#12361354)
> What I don't get about this is why trigger warnings and safe spaces always seem to get lumped together in discussions like this.

Because they are involve quite similar problems (safe for whom and from what? Warnings for which specific of the billions of potential PTSD triggers?) and are typically advocated for together, by the same people, as linked demands, to serve similar broad purposes.

> But trigger warnings are a really simple common courtesy.

No, they aren't. They are neither simple, nor are they, in fact, a common courtesy (whether or not you think they should be a common courtesy.)

> There was a popular meme spread around the Fourth of July to be considerate of veterans who may be distressed by the sound of fireworks.

There were actual several different ones, most of which were variations on combat veterans with signs at their homes asking for consideration and restraint.

> If you think this is a consideration worth extending to a veteran, it seems perfectly consistent that you'd want survivors of rape or abuse to know that a discussion of rape or abuse was coming up.

(1) Expecting people to, proactively and without knowledge of the particular trauma experienced by or triggers relevant to the audience, provide "trigger warnings" is exactly the reverse of the kind of specific and personal request for consideration at issue in the meme, and

(2) Triggering with PTSD is, in fact, quite complicated, but most often (AFAIK) involves sensory stimuli that are associated with the instance(s) of trauma producing the condition, such as sights, sounds, smells, etc. that were present during the trauma. Discussion of the class of event that relates to the trauma may be areas of strong emotional context and political sensitivity to many people (whether or not they are victims of that particular kind of trauma), but nothing I've read of actual PTSD and triggering suggests that they are particular likely to be triggers in the strict sense, even to victims of the trauma under discussion -- even to victims that do have PTSD and do have genuine, identifiable triggers.

(3) Proactive trigger warnings not based on the real known specific triggers applicable to a specific audience, if one isn't to give priority to certain type of traumas and certain presumed triggers associated with that trauma as "more deserving", quickly turn everything into a mass of warnings, most of which are irrelevant even to people who have PTSD originating in the type of trauma the warning is focused on.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by jpfed on Thursday August 25, 2016 @02:54PM (#12361464)
I think you're making this way more complicated than it needs to be.

The point of extending the courtesy of trigger warnings isn't that you will, with 100% certainty, prevent anyone from entering a state of psychological distress. That's obviously not attainable.

But let's not let the perfect be the enemy of the good. There's really obvious stuff that instructors could warn about, but aren't. After I posted a similar sentiment on Facebook, a TA told me about their professor showing porn (featuring torture) in class. Who could have known that the majority-female class she was showing this to would contain some rape victims that left the classroom in tears?! Totally out of the blue, that.

Now, I don't expect anyone to know that aging wood with thin brown flaking paint is evocative of the assault I experienced; that would be ridiculous. But of course descriptions of assaults themselves are going to be evocative.

In short, there's really easy low-hanging fruit here, and I hope people aren't so turned off by the unattainable goals of safe spaces and 100% trigger coverage that they don't extend the courtesy of warning for really obvious, foreseeable triggers.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by wflynny on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:05PM (#12361563)
I think that many of the arguments again safe spaces, trigger warnings, and actually most things are subject to the Nirvana Fallacy [1].

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nirvana_fallacy

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by sverige on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:46PM (#12361911)
First, the very act of learning can cause psychological distress. It may involve being forced to consider that some of your long-cherished ideas are wrong. This creates a crisis since either you abandon the wrong idea you've held or you ignore the new information you've acquired.

One of the most effective ways of learning is to hear and consider ideas opposed to the ones you currently hold. But these kinds of things (trigger warnings and safe spaces) act to prevent this. It inhibits learning. Sheltering people's preconceptions is the perfect way to prevent them from learning to think independently, which is opposite to the reason for going to school. Or at least, used to be.

Second, what the hell kind of professor shows porn to their class!? The warning required in that case is that the professor is unfit to teach, and/or the course offered is unworthy of any curriculum. I'm not a prude, and I can imagine perhaps some sort of graduate criminal psychology class where that might be justifiable, but it seems some sort of written description would do just fine even then.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by jpfed on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:56PM (#12361985)
In my grandparent post, I advocate treating trigger warnings and safe spaces separately. I have no intention of defending safe spaces in a university context.

Trigger warnings do not prevent the consideration of any particular idea. They help students choose the best time to engage with the material in question. If you've been warned that a particular piece of content is potentially disturbing, you can schedule your reading (or viewing) for when you're ready- so afterwards you can actually think about it instead of attending to your screaming autonomic nervous system.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by harmegido on Thursday August 25, 2016 @07:01PM (#12363149)
Your post is an amazing contradiction, all within about 20 seconds. An incredible read!

< One of the most effective ways of learning is to hear and consider ideas opposed to the ones you currently hold.

< Second, what the hell kind of professor shows porn to their class!?

Am I missing some joke or sarcasm? I'm normally pretty good at detecting it in text. How can you advocate for learning to explore all ideas, even if they may seem opposite to what you (or others) may hold and at the same time say its repugnant that a teacher would show a taboo idea in video form?

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by sverige on Thursday August 25, 2016 @11:44PM (#12364122)
No joke or sarcasm. While I advocate being exposed to different ideas and opinions, I still think there are some subjects that are not worthy of rational consideration as academic subjects, especially for undergrads.

I recognize this is an unpopular view. To go even further down the unpopular path, I also maintain that many of our colleges and universities have failed in their evaluation of what a formal education should include and exclude. For example, I have had the unhappy experience of hiring many new graduates who cannot write complete sentences, let alone organize their thoughts into some coherent whole with a beginning, middle, and end. I'm told that kind of thing doesn't matter any more, but I disagree. It reflects their thought process, which affects their ability to make good business decisions.

Also, parent post was about the trauma caused when rape victims were exposed to same without warning. Apparently it's not that uncommon to think this subject is taboo for a reason.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by r_smart on Friday August 26, 2016 @11:52AM (#12367062)
I'm confused. Did she spring the porn on them? Did she just hit play as soon as everyone sat down without preamble or context? The students had no opportunity to object or excuse themselves beforehand? If that's how that actually played out, then that professor is either tone-deaf, or used to students with more...mettle?
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by aninhumer on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:16PM (#12361650)
Indeed. The term "trigger warning" seems to have been coined to give unjustified moral weight to the idea of content warnings, by implying their absence causes PTSD attacks, rather than just being material upsetting to many people.

And I can't help thinking that, like many ideas from social justice, overly moralising a reasonable idea has made it much less palatable that it might otherwise have been.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by flubert on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:45PM (#12361895)
>And I can't help thinking that, like many ideas from social justice, overly moralising a reasonable idea has made it much less palatable that it might otherwise have been.

...Sounds familiar...

"...much leftist behavior is not rationally calculated to be of benefit to the people whom the leftists claim to be trying to help. For example, if one believes that affirmative action is good for black people, does it make sense to demand affirmative action in hostile or dogmatic terms? Obviously it would be more productive to take a diplomatic and conciliatory approach that would make at least verbal and symbolic concessions to white people who think that affirmative action discriminates against them. But leftist activists do not take such an approach because it would not satisfy their emotional needs."

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/longterm/unabo...

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by adrianratnapala on Thursday August 25, 2016 @03:01PM (#12361523)
>> But trigger warnings are a really simple common courtesy.

>No, they aren't. They are neither simple, nor are they,

You are mostly right, but there is danger here.

Traditional courtesy and political correctness do overlap a lot -- they tell us to do the same sort of things. They are not the same. As you suggest, personal consideration is not the same as political sensitivity.

But when the backlash against PC comes, that too is a kind of political sensitivity. Fear of being PC can lead people to be offensive when they would otherwise have been polite.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by weberc2 on Thursday August 25, 2016 @04:38PM (#12362298)
Clarifying question: What do you mean by "fear of being PC"? I'm a bit confused about the scenario you're describing.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by Solarsail on Thursday August 25, 2016 @06:10PM (#12362887)
Not the GP, but referring to the more broad anti-PC movement... Lets say The War On (the war on) Christmas. Fear of being PC in a context like that may work out as somebody avoiding the term "Hanukkah", even while speaking about / to a Jewish person, for fear of papering over Christmas, or looking like they're trying to change the name of the holiday.

Some other anti-PC things, like use of the term "black people" in preference to "people of color" or "african-americans"; Or describing men and women in drastically different terms, or painting them as inevitably vastly different (to avoid papering over the differences or making them look non-existent) are their own kind of cultural sensitivity. Or in some cases, even a similar sort of language policing that has long been attributed to political-correctness, just on avoiding terms that people view as originating from it.

Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by weberc2 on Thursday August 25, 2016 @07:37PM (#12363309)
Thanks for explaining that. Is this a thing that happens? I've heard of Christians grumble when the PC crowd demands that some business/school/etc stop using Christmas-specific greetings/decorations/etc. I've also heard white people grumble when the PC crowd insists everyone use a new designation for 'African Americans', but I've never heard of anyone actually exerting social pressure on others to use un-PC terms. In other words, I've never heard of anyone being told off for saying "African-Americans" or "Happy Holidays". Perhaps my experiences are atypical?
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by dragonwriter on Friday August 26, 2016 @09:02AM (#12365876)
My experiences (including through the American mass media) are the reverse of yours where Christmas is concerned. I've literally never seen someone attacked for references to Christmas, but i have seen a larger faction complaining about a "War on Christmas" and attacking people and institutions for using genetic holiday greetings, etc., and not specifically acknowledging Christmas, even sometimes attacking, on this basis, institutions which do specifically acknowledge Christmas out of hypersensitivity.
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by weberc2 on Friday August 26, 2016 @10:24AM (#12366466)
Wow, this surprises me, as I've been surrounded by Christians most of my life. I'm less surprised by the media, however--they're not very charitable in their representations of Christians (e.g., the Starbucks cup fiasco was literally one guy complaining about the cup design, but the media made it out to be some sizable portion of Christians). At any rate, do you perceive anti-PC pressure to be so prevalent as to be a legitimate concern? Do you think it would sway the speech of the average person toward legitimately offensive terms?
Re:University of Chicago: ‘We Do Not Support So-Called Trigg... by dragonwriter on Thursday August 25, 2016 @09:40PM (#12363797)
"black people" isn't necessarily anti-PC. Lots of people identify that way in preference to African-American. (And PoC is a wider group, not an equivalent alternative.)