News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm by adwn on Monday August 22, 2016 @02:02AM (#12334387)
Your proposal for immediate panic is an unnecessary overreaction.

> it sounds like we don't get faster or cheaper CPUs

The progress in desktop CPUs has been a near-plateau for several years now.

> bigger CPU caches

Diminishing returns have been hit several years ago.

> more CPU cores

Dito for most use cases.

> more RAM

Dito for most use cases.

> better or cheaper GPUs

GPUs have become so fast and cheap that integrated GPUs are good enough for most use cases.

> better/cheaper LED lights or OLED screens

I don't think they are related to the semiconductor nodes of digital logic?

> So the whole show just stops, like a high-speed train hitting a wall.

No, the train has already started slowing down several kilometers away, and most people on it have realized it. There will be no wall-hitting.

> Steel is now a base commodity

Steel may be a commodity, but the steel-using industry (in this analogy, the software industry) is alive and well.

> no one is waiting to upgrade all of their steel structures to some next generation steel alloy that will justify the massive expense of a complete "hardware upgrade."

This is actually a good thing. Besides, the sentiment "no need to optimize, just wait a year and computers will be fast enough" died over ten years ago and was stupid to begin with.

> our global economy seem to be fundamentally dependent on technology consumption cycles stemming from Moore's Law

It's really, really not. At least not outside of the SV-startup-scene cognitive bubble.

Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm by jdietrich on Monday August 22, 2016 @03:31AM (#12334670)
IT infrastructure consumes a non-trivial proportion of global electricity production, ~10% by some estimates. That consumption is growing at an alarming rate. Most of our electricity still comes from coal.

Performance-per-core may have stagnated, but performance-per-watt continues to improve at an exponential rate. Without the efficiency dividend provided by Moore's Law, IT infrastructure could become one of the biggest obstacles in our transition to sustainable energy.

Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm by snovv_crash on Monday August 22, 2016 @03:21AM (#12334640)
> This is actually a good thing. Besides, the sentiment "no need to optimize, just wait a year and computers will be fast enough" died over ten years ago and was stupid to begin with.

Ruby, Python, PHP :-/

Maybe with the next few years of performance not improving developers will wake up to the fact that doing stuff in a slow language limits the scale you can push it to.

Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm by cstejerean on Monday August 22, 2016 @03:31AM (#12334672)
Or maybe most developers aren't worried about the scale you can push something too. Most projects never go anywhere. If one turns into a runaway success you can deal with performance later. Designing everything as if it is going to require Google scale infrastructure is a good way to get distracted by cool technology and procrastinate on actually solving any useful problems.
Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm by adwn on Monday August 22, 2016 @05:11AM (#12335005)
Thankfully, programmers are already waking up to the fact that C and Python are not the only choices. Compare the success of Rust.
Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm by ido on Monday August 22, 2016 @08:18AM (#12335736)
I was astonished how fast plain-old JS has become (probably closer to c++ than to Ruby or Python, in terms of performance - even more impressive with support for stuff such as asm.js).

And recent versions of ECMAScript/JS (which are gradually albeit slowly become more and more available for real-world usage) actually make for a pretty nice language.

Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm by n00b101 on Monday August 22, 2016 @02:22AM (#12334441)
If I can summarize what you are saying, we have been experiencing early symptoms of end of Moore's Law for the past 5 to 10 years, and nothing drastic has happened yet, so there's nothing to worry about?

Consider the possibility that such a narrative is simply describing a "slow-motion train wreck" as opposed to the absence of a "train wreck?"

There is no doubt that the slow-down has been occurring for several years. One turning point was the collapse of Dennard Scaling around 2005, which led to stalling CPU clock speeds and the "multi-core crisis." I know that CPU clock speed has plateaued over a decade ago. I have not tracked costs, cache sizes, and other factors as closely, but comments here seem to be confirming that many factors have been stalled for the past 5 to 10 years (somewhere between the failure of Dennard Scaling and 28nm nodes). There have been other slow-motion slowdowns happening as well, including the collapse of PC sales growth and now the emerging collapse of smartphone sales growth. The fact that this has been happening for "a while" does not make me feel any more at ease.

To be frank, I am less confident in your comments regarding the dependence (or lack thereof) of global economic growth on technology consumption. I beg to differ that it is just a "SV-startup-scene cognitive bubble" ... I'm pretty sure technology is systemically important to global economic growth.

Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm by aleksei on Monday August 22, 2016 @02:52AM (#12334540)
This is OT, but I can't wrap my head around the reverence of global economic growth. Surely it is unsustainable in the long run. It would seem far better if people weren't required to buy a new, slightly shinier, device every few years just to keep society from collapsing.

As for the stalling of technological progress & sales, I would venture it's partly because the technology has caught up with other industries; eg. I can now watch HD movies on demand on my smartphone, at practically no cost. While it may be impractical to design smaller CPUs, there is also no incentive to do that, as people don't really have a need for it (also, see the rise in high end GPUs for VR gear, since that's what people want). However, I'd say there are other avenues of progress available than mere clock speeds, eg. energy consumption. I doubt marketing departments around the world will shrug and say 'Well, we had a good run, now it's time to call it a day'. Although that's what I'd hope for.

Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm by skybrian on Monday August 22, 2016 @03:20AM (#12334637)
The thing is, we're not actually all in the same industry. Companies that sell phones might not be so happy if sales level off or decline, but others will do fine. On the software side, there are plenty of ways to innovate without the hardware getting better.

If people stop upgrading phones, all the companies writing software to run on phones can still do their thing. Uber and AirBnB aren't really going to care; their apps already work. New businesses can come along based on mobile phone apps that put today's hardware to good use, even if the specs don't get any better.

Or looking at entertainment, the game industry doesn't actually depend on better hardware. If the VR thing turns out to be a fad, game designers will still manage to come up with innovative new video games for existing platforms, and people will keep playing them. (Minecraft doesn't require the latest hardware.)

Also, the design of phones can improve even if the raw hardware specs for CPU or memory aren't any better. You can see hardware innovations in other areas (like new sensors). Most recently, the fingerprint sensor is a good improvement.

There are all sorts of opportunities for innovation and refinement that have nothing to do with Moore's law.

Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm by jacquesm on Monday August 22, 2016 @05:23AM (#12335061)
When phones were wired you didn't 'upgrade' your phone for years if not decades.

All the end of Moore's law indicates is the end of the free lunch: free performance increase for software without any work on that software.

So instead of 'doom and gloom' I predict a very healthy re-surgence in reduction of bloat and efficiency, something that as far as I'm concerned can't happen fast enough.

FWIW my cell phone is 6 years old and as long as it works I'll happily use it. If a phone is a status symbol or a fashion accessory then there are plenty of ways to get people to upgrade even if the underlying tech doesn't change so I'm quite sure that manufacturers will find a way to re-package the same tech in ways that allows them to sell into the elective replacement market.

Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm by brian-armstrong on Monday August 22, 2016 @02:41AM (#12334497)
Most software companies won't have a lot of exposure here, since they just depend on the devices being out there. As long as there's no shortage of ideas, software advancements are still possible.

There is certainly quite a lot of downside for hardware and device companies, though, and it's hard to guess how that will also ripple into companies that just do software

Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm by adwn on Monday August 22, 2016 @05:57AM (#12335186)
> If I can summarize what you are saying, we have been experiencing early symptoms of end of Moore's Law for the past 5 to 10 years, and nothing drastic has happened yet, so there's nothing to worry about?

Yes, and what's more, the software industry seems to be stronger than ever.

> To be frank, I am less confident in your comments regarding the dependence (or lack thereof) of global economic growth on technology consumption.

Oh no, I think a large part of global economic growth depends on technology, I just don't think it depends on continued exponential improvements in the underlying semiconductor process nodes. There are other ways to innovate than just relying on automatic hardware improvements.

Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm by UweSchmidt on Monday August 22, 2016 @05:13AM (#12335019)
Excellent point. We have received technological advancement reliably and automatically for a long time. "Oops looks like we can have navigation software on the phone, just like that." - "Oh and VR goggles have just become viable, thanks Moore's Law".

There is plenty of stuff to do with our current hardware, but a new breakthrough would be nice.

Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm by imtringued on Monday August 22, 2016 @10:15AM (#12336463)
The jump from 28nm to 14nm for graphics cards enabled a massive jump for mobile graphics card made by nvidia. They are no longer a seperate product from the desktop cards. The difference is so massive that even the lowest end model, the 1060, is 15% faster than the highest end mobile graphics card (980M) from the last generation.
Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm by tmikaeld on Monday August 22, 2016 @02:14AM (#12334411)
"GPUs have become so fast and cheap that integrated GPUs are good enough for most use cases."

Except for realistic VR I'd argue, this will be an issue.

Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm by adwn on Monday August 22, 2016 @05:25AM (#12335073)
I agree that not having realistic VR due to a lack of hardware performance would be sad, but my arguments mostly concerned the global economic collapse (or rather, a lack thereof) mentioned in the parent comment.
Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm by tmikaeld on Monday August 22, 2016 @03:29PM (#12338752)
Yes of course, I'm not disagreeing with that - just adding that VR is a difficult case right now and something that i don't think can be solved with software or hardware in the short term.
Re:What Transistors Will Look Like at 5nm by jon_richards on Monday August 22, 2016 @02:46AM (#12334520)
640K ought to be enough for anyone.