News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by Normal_gaussian on Sunday August 21, 2016 @12:07PM (#12331367)
> Maybe teach kids in school how to use the health care system (hey, why not NHS ed alongside drivers ed or sex ed?).

We should probably break the news to her that there is no "drivers ed" in the UK.

But she is right. The NHS can be great, but the way the government is fucking with it at the moment will prove disastrous. It is education, not privatisation, those are the answers to the problems of the NHS.

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by arethuza on Sunday August 21, 2016 @12:11PM (#12331388)
I suspect that some of the meddling with the NHS is intended to be disastrous so that public opinion is more likely to accept profit-generating private schemes.

NB Some schools (at least here in Scotland) do offer classes on the theory part of the driving test as "interest" courses.

Edit: I eventually found the quote that sums up the approach that is being taken with the NHS:

"Only a crisis - actual or perceived - produces real change. When that crisis occurs, the actions that are taken depend on the ideas that are lying around. That, I believe, is our basic function: to develop alternatives to existing policies, to keep them alive and available until the politically impossible becomes the politically inevitable.”

Milton Friedman

Of course, the crisis that created the NHS was WW2 - I remember my father (who served in the RAF in WW2) being pretty clear that returning to the pre-war status-quo was not an option that anyone was interested in, which is why there was such a resounding defeat of Churchill at the polls when the war ended.

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by digi_owl on Sunday August 21, 2016 @12:56PM (#12331604)
That quite can be applied to the whole neoliberal process that has been ongoing since the 80s.

First laden the public services with excessive regulations and budgetary constraints to make it crack, loudly publicizes the resulting failures, claim TINA on privatization/deregulation of the market, laugh all the way to the (offshore) bank.

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by dTal on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:14PM (#12331684)
This is indeed a classic tactic, but I'm surprised you refer to it as "neoliberal". Deregulation, privatization, and "Starve the beast" have been conservative platforms since Reagan.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by oriolid on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:23PM (#12331734)
Neoliberal is effectively conservative with less guns and religion.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by dragonwriter on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:27PM (#12331758)
"Neoliberal" is a particular economic approach within the broad umbrella of political conservatism. (In the US this is somewhat confused because lots of the Democratic Party is neoliberal, but the Democratic Party is basically a coalition of moderate left to center-right, leaning more to latter.)
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by zigzigzag on Sunday August 21, 2016 @03:31PM (#12332345)
Services like the NHS are money pits: no matter how much money they are given they will always be broke, and given the total lack of accountability inherent in the system there will always be regulations trying to improve their efficiency. Thus ANY public healthcare service, at ANY time, will be perceived by some large part of the population as "laden with excessive regulations and budgetary constraints".

This is not some neoliberal conspiracy, it is the natural consequence of any system which allocates money without sufficient accountability.

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by dageshi on Sunday August 21, 2016 @12:19PM (#12331426)
I think the NHS is a massive government department that uses a huge amount of money (legitimately) and absolutely no government is capable of being in power and not "meddling" with it.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by arethuza on Sunday August 21, 2016 @12:22PM (#12331439)
One thing to note is as this is the UK - we actually have four National Health Services, one for each country:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Health_Service

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by k-mcgrady on Sunday August 21, 2016 @12:29PM (#12331468)
Which is idiotic. e.g. if you get tests done in one country and move to another they cannot access your scans/x-rays and end up just doing them again. Waste of money but more importantly the case history is getting distorted as you're repeating it and likely missing notes the original doctors had made.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by vertex-four on Sunday August 21, 2016 @12:44PM (#12331529)
On the other hand... for a lot of things, NHS Scotland handles long-term healthcare better than NHS England. NHS England essentially got forced into creating a watered-down version of the Gender Reassignment Protocol a few years after Scotland implemented theirs, and from my understanding it's incredibly difficult to get anyone to follow it. I wouldn't give up NHS Scotland for the English system - and I think many Scots would agree. (And I voted No to independence!)
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by digi_owl on Sunday August 21, 2016 @12:51PM (#12331575)
As an outsider my understanding is that one of the first things Scotland did after getting the ability to do so, was to roll back may of the recent changes to the NHS. This to the point that Norwegian politicians, the nation going through something akin to the Thatcher-Blair process, went visiting.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by zigzigzag on Sunday August 21, 2016 @03:32PM (#12332351)
Scotland can do this partly because it is heavily subsidised by the English. If the subsidies vanished I think NHS Scotland's performance would be significantly worse.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by pjc50 on Sunday August 21, 2016 @06:09PM (#12332942)
This is difficult to do the accounting on, but almost certainly not true.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by niels_olson on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:11PM (#12331675)
Health data, including imaging and genomics, should be held by third party custodians and delivered as needed to registered providers. The data can be handled by the provider's viewing system. The cost can be covered by charging the system providing the care a fee: part transmission, part long-term storage.

This is already starting to happen, but is still regionalized and very fragmented.

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by digi_owl on Sunday August 21, 2016 @12:49PM (#12331562)
UK for all intents and purposes, is four nations sharing a crown. Not unheard of in European history, just look at the likes of Denmark-Norway, but perhaps the only one that has lasted to the present day.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by kalleboo on Sunday August 21, 2016 @12:53PM (#12331582)
And I imagine the long-term goal would be to share the records among EU countries (well, not the UK anymore) since healthcare is valid across the union, but language barriers make that pretty difficult
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by arethuza on Sunday August 21, 2016 @12:45PM (#12331535)
Well, that's the UK for you - we don't have single legal or educational systems either!
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by k-mcgrady on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:16PM (#12331698)
I didn't really put my point across properly. Separation is important so citizens in each country can tailor services to their specific needs but data sharing should still be possible and automatic.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by gerbilly on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:45PM (#12331837)
[dead]
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by ZenoArrow on Sunday August 21, 2016 @12:39PM (#12331510)
The Conservatives are so brazen about it they'll even spell it out in writing. This is the Google Books synopsis for the book Privatising the World by Conservative MP Oliver Letwin:

"Identifies the reasons why governments in a number of different countries have chosen to privatise their nationalised industries. The opposition to privatisation and the techniques used to overcome this opposition are also analysed."

https://books.google.co.uk/books/about/Privatising_the_World...

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by fooster on Sunday August 21, 2016 @02:07PM (#12331963)
I'd think the UK population are a bit gunshy about privatization after privatisation of British Rail. I'd also think that the US would have learned their lesson by looking an Enron... but since when have facts gotten in the way of a good story?
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by pjc50 on Sunday August 21, 2016 @06:12PM (#12332950)
The population is quite against it, but that makes little difference when politics and the media are as dysfunctional as they are at the moment.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by ZenoArrow on Sunday August 21, 2016 @02:26PM (#12332057)
> "I'd also think that the US would have learned their lesson by looking an Enron... but since when have facts gotten in the way of a good story?"

I'm not sure what you meant by this, can you explain further?

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by fooster on Sunday August 21, 2016 @08:13PM (#12333365)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_electricity_crisis

Overall this crisis, imo, was caused by the pro-privatization advocates arguing for deregulation. The wikipedia article addresses this to some extent.

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by hansjorg on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:17PM (#12331702)
That synopsis doesn't sound very nefarious. Does the book recommend sabotage as a technique?
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by justratsinacoat on Sunday August 21, 2016 @02:06PM (#12331959)
To anyone who intuitively understands why the maintenance of human health and well-being might suffer for being corrupted by vested interests who are more interested in said vesting than human health and well-being (ie, "opposition to privatisation"), the disturbing aspect is precisely how non-nefarious and academic the synopsis seems.

"Starve the beast" and other traditional conservative anti-public-service techniques are functionally sabotage, yes. I'm not sure what other concept might succinctly describe "cut as much funding as you can, then highlight the resultant disaster as proof that the private sector can do better". The cultural acceptance of the practice doesn't change what the practice is.

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by ZenoArrow on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:59PM (#12331919)
Would you class deliberate underfunding of the public sector in order to build public support for privatisation as sabotage?
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by zigzigzag on Sunday August 21, 2016 @03:34PM (#12332362)
You realise the UK has a large deficit, right? And taxes are comparable to other western countries.

The NHS will never not be broke. Your position is typical of the British left but is entirely meaningless: the government could go into Greek style debt to double the budget of the NHS tomorrow and 10 years later it'd be once again constantly broke.

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by ZenoArrow on Sunday August 21, 2016 @04:12PM (#12332524)
Depends on your definition of "broke". If you think of something that requires tax money to function as perpetually broke then you're only seeing half of the story. Do you agree that, per person, the British spend less per head on healthcare than people living in the US? If so, why do you think this is?

As I said in a different comment, many of the problems in the NHS have come from privatisation. If you want the NHS to cost less, take a look at what's happening with PFI. Just by stopping PFI funding of hospitals and going back to the old funding model of government loans at low interest rates could save huge sums of money.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/nhs/11748960/The-PFI-hospita...

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by zigzigzag on Sunday August 21, 2016 @04:16PM (#12332541)
By "broke" I mean telling the government that it desperately needs more money or else services will start failing.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by ZenoArrow on Sunday August 21, 2016 @04:34PM (#12332624)
Fine, that's your definition of broke. How about the rest of the points from the same comment.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by zigzigzag on Monday August 22, 2016 @04:21AM (#12334840)
I do agree that the UK spends less per head than the US does and gets more for it. But the USA has one of the world's most dysfunctional health systems. Constantly comparing the NHS to it, or worse, implying that people face a binary choice between the US system or the UK system, is a fallacy that ignores the highly capable and often very efficient healthcare systems in other countries. Which don't seem to suffer the same ills of the NHS.

It's also not the case that the UK vs US comparison is one of government vs capitalism. All healthcare systems have heavy government involvement and distortion of the healthcare market, and this is fine, because developed societies always choose these problems over the much larger problem of poor people being unable to afford healthcare.

PFI schemes have not been good value for money and were essentially a trick to hide the ballooning costs of the NHS from a population that can't treat the topic rationally. Unfortunately, too many people in the UK look at this sort of thing and instead of saying "wow our government is really bad at public procurement, we should give them less power" conclude something along the lines of "oh noes, they should have guessed that trying to buy things from companies would lead to disaster - the solution is a fully state run economy!"

All kinds of organisations manage to procure services and investment from the private sector, all over the world, every day ... without problems. PFI boiled down to a complicated kind of loan that let Labour do what it always seems to try and do: massively increase spending on the public sector without raising taxes. No surprise that they paid a very high interest rate for such a thing.

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by ZenoArrow on Monday August 22, 2016 @04:49PM (#12339325)
> "Constantly comparing the NHS to it, or worse, implying that people face a binary choice between the US system or the UK system, is a fallacy that ignores the highly capable and often very efficient healthcare systems in other countries. Which don't seem to suffer the same ills of the NHS."

I'm glad you could admit that the NHS wasn't the worst system out there. As for better systems, I'm not saying the NHS is perfect, what I am saying is that it can be improved by stopping the drive towards privatisation, as this drive is making the NHS less efficient at spending money on healthcare, not more efficient. Furthermore, even with these inefficiencies, the NHS continues to offer a cost-effective service, and I don't even need to use the US healthcare system to compare it to. The UK spends less per person on healthcare than France and Germany, for example:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_h...

The NHS isn't a money pit, it's a bargain. If you made it more efficient by getting rid of the privatisation efforts, it could be even more of a bargain.

> "PFI boiled down to a complicated kind of loan that let Labour do what it always seems to try and do: massively increase spending on the public sector without raising taxes. No surprise that they paid a very high interest rate for such a thing."

This is where your partisan bias is blinding you. PFI wasn't just popular with New Labour, it's been popular with the Conservatives that replaced them in power. If the Conservatives are supposedly more fiscally responsible, why do they continue to use expensive PFI schemes to fund government spending?

http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2011/apr/18/george-osbor...

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by zigzigzag on Tuesday August 23, 2016 @08:23AM (#12343088)
That article dates from 2011. PFI is being phased out. Look at the graph in section A here:

https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachm...

PFI reached its peak in 2007. Current number of deals being added are at the level they were at in 1995.

It's worth asking why any new deals are being signed at all, but when we're down to the level of 8 per year (vs 65 at the peak of New Labour) it's fair to say that they're much less popular than they once were.

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by bahjoite on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:54PM (#12331889)
> We should probably break the news to her that there is no "drivers ed" in the UK.

But there is "cycling proficiency"!

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by raverbashing on Sunday August 21, 2016 @12:42PM (#12331521)
> We should probably break the news to her that there is no "drivers ed" in the UK.

There isn't? Care to explain?

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by PeterisP on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:06PM (#12331650)
There's no assumption that all students will need or want to learn how to drive, so it's not a part of any standard curriculum; you pass the exam and get a driving licence when and if you're ready for that.

Many do it soon after they can, many do it later as adults, and many never do. In UK only ~35% of adults aged 17-20 and ~65% of 20-29 have a driving licence; I assume that this is a bit different in USA.

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by majewsky on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:32PM (#12331783)
Wait, do you mean that in the US, driver's ed is part of the high school curriculum? That sounds positively bizarre to me as a German.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by ars on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:49PM (#12331860)
It's not, I have no idea what the person you replied to is talking about.

It's a private school. Most kids learn by their parents teaching them. If the parent can not do it for whatever reason, then they register with a drivers ed school, and the teacher teaches them.

In some states if you take the theory classes [not the road practice] you get a discount on your insurance - that sometimes is part of highschool.

Every state is different though, some require a logbook with road hours, some don't, some have more theory classes, some less. It varies a lot.

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by groovy2shoes on Sunday August 21, 2016 @02:39PM (#12332121)
It varies state-to-state. I grew up in Florida, where I started learning to drive at age 14. I was taught entirely by my mother, and I earned my learner's permit at 15, then was fully licensed at 16 after passing the tests.

About five months after I was issued my driver's license by the state of Florida, we moved to North Carolina, where driver's education is compulsory for people under 18. They would not issue me a North Carolina driver's license unless I completed driver's ed., even though I was already licensed in the state of Florida.

As a result, I enrolled in driver's ed. via my high school. Classes took place in the afternoon after all my regular classes were finished. Then, while my classmates were waiting for their rides, I got in my car and drove myself home. For the on-road portion of the coursework, I drove myself to and from the school on Saturday mornings and hopped in the "Student Driver" car. My instructor, knowing I already knew how to drive pretty well, just had me drive him on his errands -- grab a coffee at McDonald's, return some tapes to Blockbuster, deposit his paycheck at the bank, etc.

It was bullshit, but I had to do it to obtain an NC driver's license.

Of course, after college I moved to northern Virginia for work, and getting my VA license was as easy as filling out a form and showing them my NC license. Done! The VA DMV puts the NC DMV to shame in many ways, including efficiency. (In NC, we also have separate DMV offices for licenses and tags. Pain in the ass!)

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by dtparr on Sunday August 21, 2016 @03:10PM (#12332242)
There are many places where it's not a private school. In the places I'm familiar with, it's an elective. I had both theory and road practice as one of my (standard, school-hours) classes sophomore year. The instructors were basically all sports coaches.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by madaxe_again on Sunday August 21, 2016 @12:46PM (#12331546)
You buy a copy of the highway code and you learn it. You then do a theory test, which has a relatively high pass mark - covers rules of the road, hazard perception, etc. Then you do your practical test. Most folks seem to fail at least once. I failed twice.

I've both UK and US licenses - did drivers ed in illinois in the 90's, aged 15. Watching gruesome films didn't make me a better driver, and I remember being stunned when I was told I'd passed - we didn't even go on a public road!

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by muzzio on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:00PM (#12331618)
I can tell you this is pretty vastly different now. I also grew up in Illinois, and after passing the theory test you are only granted a learner's permit. To obtain a license you need 50 hours of supervised practice behind the wheel, at least 10 of those hours being at night. You're then given a practical test at the DMV where you take public roads with a designated instructor.

At least, that's the process to get a license before you're 18, I think after 18 you just need to pass the practical test. And since usually the person filling out the 50 hours sheet is one of your parents it's definitely possible to just lie about it.

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by kalleboo on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:25PM (#12331742)
Obviously this all varies wildly by state
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by kennell on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:04PM (#12331639)
I am curious, what does the practical test consist of?
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by xtreme on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:17PM (#12331703)
In Ohio, it consists of about 10-15 minutes of driving around public roads following the instructions followed by a parallel parking test using cones. Most other states are pretty similar.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by kennell on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:36PM (#12331799)
Would you consider it difficult to pass? Are there any numbers what the failure rate is?

Just for comparison, here in Germany, you have to take a 14 hours of theory lessons and then do a theoretical test (which has a 25%+ failure rate). Once you passed that, you have to take 20 hours of mandatory driver training with a certified instructor. The instructor will decide if you need additional training hours (up to another 8 hours). The practical test then consists of 25-30 minutes of driving and parking (in a real parking spot, not cones). This practical test also has a 25%+ failure rate. Also, all that happens in a car with manual transmission.

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by omegaham on Sunday August 21, 2016 @03:27PM (#12332323)
> Would you consider it difficult to pass?

No. It's literally driving around a few streets, stopping at a stop sign / stop light, and (maybe) parallel parking. I had to do it with real cars, which in retrospect were junkers that the DMV had for the purpose.

> Are there any numbers what the failure rate is?

Massachusetts provides a list of drivers ed schools with their pass rates - it seems to vary from 50% to 90%. Cutting that in half and adding a little bit, (the highest pass rates come from large, successful schools) the pass rate seems to be around 75% or so.

However, this is for teenagers who went through driver's ed - adults have a much, much easier time with the test because they're more mature.

Also, it greatly depends on the state. When I was in the Marines, I had the wonderful task of teaching boots how to drive so that they could get an Arizona driver's license. Their test was literally just driving around the block, no parallel parking involved.

I took the test in a manual because that's what my dad had, but most take it in an automatic. In all seriousness, though, a manual really isn't that hard once you spend a few hours stalling at every stop sign in a suburban neighborhood.

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by detaro on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:43PM (#12331828)
Technically doesn't have to be a manual, if you're fine with not being allowed to drive a manual afterwards. So basically only done by people with medical conditions that can't drive a manual anyways.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by kalleboo on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:26PM (#12331749)
For comparison, in Sweden the practical test is 45 minutes of driving on public roads (including a highway) where things such as eco driving and safe driving (not slowing down past a parked bus is an automatic fail) are also judged. The standard is doing it in a manual transmission car and a minority choose the exception of doing it in an automatic. Sweden's a Nordic country so we also have a mandatory snow driving (skid pad) experience before you can take the test.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by fastball on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:42PM (#12331820)
Yeah, I'm pretty sure nowadays in any state, you need to either have a requisite number of hours behind the wheel or to pass an actual driving test.

The driver's test is still easier in the US than in the UK.

Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by sim0n on Sunday August 21, 2016 @12:48PM (#12331554)
You are not taught how drive as part of the curriculum in England and is not offered to students by schools like it is in the US.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by kec on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:15PM (#12331695)
It isn't part of the curriculum for (at least most) US schools either. Some schools offer it as an elective or after school program, but that's it.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by learc83 on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:15PM (#12331690)
The majority of the schools in the US no longer offer driver's ed either.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by teamonkey on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:29PM (#12331767)
There is, but not in the same way. In the UK driving lessons are not typically taught in schools. At age 17 you can apply for a provisional driving licence, which allows you to drive on most roads with 'L plates' attached and a fully-licenced driver in the passenger seat. Many people pay for lessons, but it's possible to pass your test after only informal practice. There's a theory test that must be passed before taking your practical test; your practical test will be on real roads and not an area designed for that purpose.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by fastball on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:38PM (#12331806)
Driver's Ed isn't taught in schools either... it can be offered, but I've never heard of mandatory driver's ed at any High School in the US.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by jacalata on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:43PM (#12331830)
"in schools" doesn't have to mean "compulsory"
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by fastball on Sunday August 21, 2016 @03:31PM (#12332346)
Offering it in schools makes sense... it's education. If "compulsory" wasn't being implied, then it's an obvious non-issue, and I'm not sure why anyone brought it up.
Re:An American Doctor Experiences the NHS Again by jacalata on Sunday August 21, 2016 @10:27PM (#12333745)
Because they were commenting on the fact that it isn't offered in the UK in schools at all, which the author didn't appear to realise. I don't see anyone calling it an "issue" at all.