Re:The Japanese Urban Zoning System
by contingencies on Sunday August 21, 2016 @01:59AM
(#12329622)
which were never really true
{{citation-needed}}
we are discussing Tokyo in the late 20th and early 21st centuries
OK, scope difference. 'The Japanese Urban Zoning System' != modern Tokyo.
Demonstrably untrue. During the late 19th century, and most of the 20th century, protests were a significant aspect of Japanese society -- more so than in many western countries.
I would argue that extreme temporary conditions (war, forced modernization/industrialization) are a skewed sample of a society's normal behavior.
If you were talking about...
The title is 'The Japanese Urban Zoning System': city street layouts are closer to this than architecture.
Within Kyoto, the urban architecture is not really Chinese, even if the street layout used to be.
I would argue that modern architecture in Kyoto is demonstrably descended from Tang Dynasty woodworking techniques, courtyard layouts and Chang'an-style high density urban layout. The street layout is still based on Chang'an.
{{citation-needed}}
we are discussing Tokyo in the late 20th and early 21st centuries
OK, scope difference. 'The Japanese Urban Zoning System' != modern Tokyo.
Demonstrably untrue. During the late 19th century, and most of the 20th century, protests were a significant aspect of Japanese society -- more so than in many western countries.
I would argue that extreme temporary conditions (war, forced modernization/industrialization) are a skewed sample of a society's normal behavior.
If you were talking about...
The title is 'The Japanese Urban Zoning System': city street layouts are closer to this than architecture.
Within Kyoto, the urban architecture is not really Chinese, even if the street layout used to be.
I would argue that modern architecture in Kyoto is demonstrably descended from Tang Dynasty woodworking techniques, courtyard layouts and Chang'an-style high density urban layout. The street layout is still based on Chang'an.