Re:The Six-Lesson Schoolteacher
by jerf on Wednesday March 31, 2010 @02:58PM
(#1232712)
"If school really was invented for the sole purpose of creating a generation of unthinking worker drones, then this means that everything that we believe in - capitalism, the economies of scale, marketing - hinges on the creation of a dumb populace."
No! It means that over a hundred years ago, people with attitudes we would today call fairly socialist, communist, or perhaps most likely fascist thought their success depended on the creation of a dumb populace. (Regardless of how successful they were and how that came from capitalism, they were very casually command-and-control people, with no belief that it could be any other way; exactly which style of command-and-control you ascribe to them hardly matters, really.) It does not prove they were correct.
Even today people commit the crime of thinking the next 20 years will be just like today, but people suffered from this problem even more so 100 years ago. No concept of an information or service economy, just factory drones forevermore into the future.
You can see this all over the literature; for one classic example see Brave New World.
"We have no alternative to school, ... far cries from the economies of scale afforded to the capitalistic society."
Self-directed learning with heavy computer involvement and individual tutoring follow-ups and check-ups without masses of children in lockstep. Serious re-thinks of the core curricula, which can only be described as inherited, not carefully-considered. The tech for this is currently rapidly developing, but we aren't there quite yet. But it'll be there long before society adjusts to the idea.
Interestingly, while schools have been out-of-step with what the economy needed for at least the last 30-40 years if Gatto is correct, it is arguable that we had no practical choice; there is no way that the sketch I provided above could have worked in 1980, the tech was simply not there no matter how much money you threw at it.
Yes, I am fully aware this is little more than a sketch. But this is just a HN comment, after all.
I'd also prescribe a healthy recognition of the fact that what matters is what sort of adult pops out, and not what stuff was "covered". The fact that geometry is in the curriculum is virtually irrelevant if effectively nobody remembers it when they are even 4 years out of school. A serious rethink should be based on this fact. Obviously, geometry is not critical to a society because regardless of how hard we cover it is school the citizenry in fact does not remember or understand it.
(Note: It is distinctly possible that when Marx claimed that capitalism would be dehumanizing and evil, that to the extent it was true, it was true because people read his works and figured if they weren't dehumanizing their workers they weren't doing it right. Was it all a self-fulfilling prophecy? Your knee-jerk answer is too simple, regardless of which way your knee jerked.)
No! It means that over a hundred years ago, people with attitudes we would today call fairly socialist, communist, or perhaps most likely fascist thought their success depended on the creation of a dumb populace. (Regardless of how successful they were and how that came from capitalism, they were very casually command-and-control people, with no belief that it could be any other way; exactly which style of command-and-control you ascribe to them hardly matters, really.) It does not prove they were correct.
Even today people commit the crime of thinking the next 20 years will be just like today, but people suffered from this problem even more so 100 years ago. No concept of an information or service economy, just factory drones forevermore into the future.
You can see this all over the literature; for one classic example see Brave New World.
"We have no alternative to school, ... far cries from the economies of scale afforded to the capitalistic society."
Self-directed learning with heavy computer involvement and individual tutoring follow-ups and check-ups without masses of children in lockstep. Serious re-thinks of the core curricula, which can only be described as inherited, not carefully-considered. The tech for this is currently rapidly developing, but we aren't there quite yet. But it'll be there long before society adjusts to the idea.
Interestingly, while schools have been out-of-step with what the economy needed for at least the last 30-40 years if Gatto is correct, it is arguable that we had no practical choice; there is no way that the sketch I provided above could have worked in 1980, the tech was simply not there no matter how much money you threw at it.
Yes, I am fully aware this is little more than a sketch. But this is just a HN comment, after all.
I'd also prescribe a healthy recognition of the fact that what matters is what sort of adult pops out, and not what stuff was "covered". The fact that geometry is in the curriculum is virtually irrelevant if effectively nobody remembers it when they are even 4 years out of school. A serious rethink should be based on this fact. Obviously, geometry is not critical to a society because regardless of how hard we cover it is school the citizenry in fact does not remember or understand it.
(Note: It is distinctly possible that when Marx claimed that capitalism would be dehumanizing and evil, that to the extent it was true, it was true because people read his works and figured if they weren't dehumanizing their workers they weren't doing it right. Was it all a self-fulfilling prophecy? Your knee-jerk answer is too simple, regardless of which way your knee jerked.)