Tyler may have talked about this elsewhere, but this post was written by Alex Tabarrok.
Re:The Japanese Urban Zoning System
by adrianratnapala on Saturday August 20, 2016 @01:30PM
(#12327498)
I'd guess the state level is natural -- but then again some states in the US (and all states in Australia) are dominated by one big city, so the state government can also be captured by NIMBYs.
Generally I dislike the way top-level governments are becoming the only game in town. But the point is to have multiple levels of government checking each other. When it comes to zoning: its the locals who are the "bad" guys.
Re:The Japanese Urban Zoning System
by twelvechairs on Saturday August 20, 2016 @06:24PM
(#12328534)
The problem is local governments are awful at planning for growth, especially in nice areas (where people actually want to live) as they tend towards no change.
I think the best solution is still planning at a local level but there should be approppriate rules from a higher level to ensure it works - usually including a growth target which must be planned for and minimum densities (allowing for some exceptions) for different kidnds of locations (greenfield, around train stations, etc)
On your other point - in my experience states tend towards the opposite - being developer lobby driven much more than nimby
While the Japanese system is implemented and managed on the national level, I can imagine this being more effective on a more granular level, while still being much higher up than the city level as to avoid the political repercussions of local special interest landowners.