This is actually a problem for all STEM and vocational programs a community college offers. It is also a problem for specialized certificate training (e.g. Commercial Drivers License, Cisco). It is not cheap to hire competent instructors. The only advantage the short term training in these circumstances has that you are more likely to be able to get an instructor for a short run or hire an outside contracting company to provide an instructor. Semester length or multi-Semester classes basically require the hiring of a faculty member.
Frankly, a lot of the vocation jobs have better pay and career advancement these days with all the infrastructure fixes, new construction, and lack of competition.
While I am sure that there are many individuals who now come in with more code experience than the typical college student in the early 90s, there is a significant aspect of "are you mature enough to teach?" and "do you have enough experience to help students that need help?"
Assisting teaching a class, maybe. But looking at the quality of the code I wrote and the advice I would give based on that code that I wrote, I would be very concerned for the future prospects of anyone who I taught when I was 21 and looking for a summer job.
The choice for CCs isn't between student teachers and experienced degree'd teachers. It's between student teachers and no teachers or teachers who know nothing about programming.
The skills needed to run a classroom and the skills needed to tutor are quite different. I am unaware of any current rules about the education-level of tutors, and I doubt there are or will be any.
> The choice for CCs isn't between student teachers and experienced degree'd teachers. It's between student teachers and no teachers or teachers who know nothing about programming.
Student teachers (unless part of a TA situation and supervised) probably aren't a solution either unless we're talking certificates and not college credits.
Determining Qualified Faculty Through HLC’s Criteria for Accreditation and Assumed Practices: http://download.hlcommission.org/FacultyGuidelines_2016_OPB....
You have a point for classrooms with kids in them. But for adults? I don't see it. I've taken many classes from adults who've never taught a class before. I've taught classes yet have had zero instruction in classroom technique. Frankly, I don't see a difference in effectiveness between them and people with teaching degrees.
Yes, for adults. There is a huge difference between good and bad teachers for continued student success. Its an important thing in learning.
Also, college students often go home for the summer, where they have a hard time finding summer jobs. A local CC offering to hire them to teach a summer class in programming would be a win-win for everyone concerned.
Of course summer attendance is less. So there are fewer classes. Why is that a problem if there are enough people wanting to learn programming in the summer to form a class?
Heck, I learned accounting in summer school. The college had 10x the number of accounting students during the rest of the year, but in the summer they still had enough to fill one class and found a local instructor who wanted to supplement his income.
Are you suggesting that should not have happened?
Plus, the accreditation rules have changed in recent years to make people without a 4 year degrees (and indeed in some areas without a Masters) to be problematic for teaching.
> to be problematic
Another example of good intentions gone awry.
Maybe other institutions could do it and get away with it. I cannot see the average CC with normal staffing, student, and rule patterns.
> Another example of good intentions gone awry.
?
We have to live with the rules the accreditation boards set. You lose your accreditation and its game over and the whole community suffers from not only the loss of a learning institution, but an employer and social work organization.
But for those in favor of bureaucratic rules over getting things done, they'll have to settle for no programming instruction in CCs.
If the course is not accredited, it doesn't transfer and it doesn't count towards a degree. If it doesn't count for any degree we might as well do a workshop with certificates and hire a one shot instructor or contract for one from a company. That is something we already do and would not trust to a student.
> But for those in favor of bureaucratic rules over getting things done, they'll have to settle for no programming instruction in CCs.
I don't think you get the whole CC thing. Not following those rules, like murdering someone, would be an death sentence.
That said the "computer electronics technology" appears to be computer repair (installation and hardware) rather than a programming. The computer programming class (just one class) is there to get an idea of what can be done. The job prospects include "computer electronics technician, computer network technician, computer systems technician, network specialist, pc specialist."
The thing that I took away from this is that if one goes anywhere where the "in the desk tech jobs" are not common (and with openings), you will find few if any programming focused certificates at community colleges. This is despite the nature of computer programming jobs often being the easiest to facilitate remote work.
I wonder how much of the lack of courses is also related to the "if you are a competent programmer and are capable of teaching others, can you find better paying jobs than working as a community college instructor on the low income side of the city?"
---
I also have a fair bit of skepticism about how well this will work based on decision fatigue (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decision_fatigue / https://effectivesoftwaredesign.com/2011/08/23/how-decision-...) that is often common in lower income households.