The article above is from 2/29/09. A 2014 article[0] shows their guilty pleas were later rejected due to their behavior, and both given larger sentences.
> Both originally agreed to spend seven years in prison, but then Ciavarella talked exclusively with Newswatch 16.
> "I loved the juvenile court, I loved helping those kids. I would never do anything to hurt a child, that's just not what I do. That's not me. I was always there for those kids. I resent the fact that people think I did something improper. I didn't do anything improper when it came to the care of those kids," said Ciavarella in July of 2009.
> Days after that interview, a federal judge rejected the guilty pleas of Ciavarella and Conahan, saying their behavior didn't really accept guilt.
[0] http://wnep.com/2014/01/26/five-years-since-ciavarella-and-c...
Mark Ciavarella (#15008-067): Ashland FCI until 30 December 2035
Michael Conahan (#15009-067): Coleman Low FCI until 18 December 2026
http://thetimes-tribune.com/news/court-denies-civarella-appe...
EDIT - You can verify this online at https://www.bop.gov/inmateloc/ and search for 15008-067
They never should have allowed the number of jointly tried cases that they did. They used joint prosecution as a tactic, combining lesser hard-to-prove charges against one defendant with severe charges against another in the same trial, relying upon the strength of the evidence against one defendant to damn them both.
Regardless, their investigation was very beneficial in the long run. Low-level corruption used to be endemic in the Scranton/Wilkes-Barre area, until the Federal government came to town. Following the "Kids for Cash" case, the area became the subject of a wide-ranging inquiry into official abuse of office.
By the time the dust settled, close to two dozen officials were criminally charged, including a state senator, a very wealthy commercial real estate developer, and two county commissioners.
I too am pleased with the outcome. However, the law is about fairness in process, not fairness in outcome. In a case like this, the judge is often so disgusted by the defendant that they make up their mind and find a legal justification afterwards.
The precedent judges set in order to convict "bad" defendants can then be used in other less serious cases. From this comes the common saying amongst lawyers, "Bad cases make bad law."
For example, raiding a paedophile's home without a warrant or probable cause is satisfying, and often just in outcome. However, it is not just in process if the judge allows the evidence to be admitted. If a precedent is set in that case, prosecutors will take it as judicial license to raid more homes without warrants. The evidence from those raids can then be admitted under whatever tortured theory the appellate judge used to ensure the paedophile was convicted.
Remember, once the government sets a precedent, there is nothing to keep them from applying it to you.
It's still unbelievable to me. These judges and contractors were well-respected members of the community. Yet they committed perhaps one of the most heinous breaches of trust possible in a justice system: selling children into prison for personal profit.
I met these men. They did not start out "evil." However, in a relatively isolated Rust Belt region, the judges are some of the most powerful political figures in the county. The conspirators messages show the slow progression from neutrality into almost gleeful corruption, as they became intoxicated with the power of the bench.
I mean, look I agree with you that they need to be closed, but there are likely better examples of them just being worse on merit, without having to dive into bribery and whatnot.