News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask News.YC: How difficult is it to break out of prevaili... by brlewis on Monday February 25, 2008 @10:29AM (#123114)
This is one of my favorite topics. I like the movie "The Nightmare Before Christmas" because it's all about being trapped in a paradigm.

I think photo sharing is trapped in the paradigm of the early adopters (photography enthusiasts), and I write about that here:

http://ourdoings.com/2007-12-19

In general, the only way to break a paradigm is to throw it very hard against the wall of reality.

For product design that means immersing yourself in what people want. Evolve as you come into contact with different needs, wants and behaviors.

Re:Ask News.YC: How difficult is it to break out of prevaili... by xirium on Monday February 25, 2008 @01:44PM (#123220)
UK industrial designers Dick Powell and Richard Seymour had a television programme called Better By Design in which they designed products immersively. They also had some other techniques. One was to seek overlooked advances in material science. Another was to seek a "standing wave" in product design. This is an element in a design which is blindly and repeatedly copied.

You may benefit from the most widespread example of this analysis because their company, Seymour Powell, inverted the cordless kettle. The initial design worked in one orientation. Copies are omni-directional.

Re:Ask News.YC: How difficult is it to break out of prevaili... by fiaz on Monday February 25, 2008 @11:01AM (#123126)
"In general, the only way to break a paradigm is to throw it very hard against the wall of reality."

That's a great quote! I'm curious to know how your photo-sharing site is exemplary of this statement. I'm not trying to be a jerk here (I think I do a great job of that with little effort!), instead I'm just trying to understand from the perspective of a potential user (or for that matter an investor) of your site who is interested in innovative thinking that is distinctly different from the superfluous ornamentation that you see in the "car of the future" picture given.

[just to be clear: I'm just asking for the sake of knowledge exchange, I am not at all a picture taker and I am not in the business of funding startups!]

Re:Ask News.YC: How difficult is it to break out of prevaili... by brlewis on Monday February 25, 2008 @11:19AM (#123139)
I was talking about finding the cracks in a paradigm that needs to break, so I hope ourdoings.com is not exemplary of it. Traditional photo sharing breaks when it hits someone who has amassed a pile of digital photos but has no time to organize them into albums. It also breaks when your peers have litle time and you email them a link to your new photos instead of having thumbnails and explanatory text right in the message.

Up until late last year the ourdoings.com paradigm broke if people had a lot of photos but no time to choose the good ones. Finding what else is broken is tough, in that people may go months without using the site (putting up more photos) without that being a problem. They know they can come back and catch up easily when they have a little time.

Re:Ask News.YC: How difficult is it to break out of prevaili... by fiaz on Monday February 25, 2008 @11:28AM (#123148)
If only "futurists" had this type of honesty about their own visions of the future then perhaps we wouldn't have so many "visions" that are obscured by more of the same.