And it wasn't just that - it was the complex system of meta-moderation. How you moderated posts was also scored.
One downside was that it could lead to a complete hive mind where your karma was dependent upon how much you thought like others.
Re:NPR Website to Get Rid of Comments
by plasticsyntax on Friday August 19, 2016 @08:29AM
(#12319544)
Meta-moderation was indeed a big part of it, and something I never saw _anywhere_ else.
Since then they seem to have eliminated that level of customization so either it wasn't working or they just didn't see it as worth reimplimenting when they moved away from their old code base.