Brokers are the worst. Their incentives are not aligned with yours on anything besides wanting to get it over with asap.
How do brokers have the gall to straight-faced sell people on this stuff?
I pray that technology can disrupt this market.
To be fair, that's occasionally exactly what you want - if you've just moved into town for the first time, for instance, and want to mitigate uncertainty (and hotel expenses) ASAP.
How can I be so sure of this?
Easy. RDNY.com has a "to the trade" division, Acmelistings.com which provides NYC real estate brokers and agents with rental apartment listings. About 2,500 agents and brokers use this service. They are aggregating listings from over 1,000 landlords and selling that info to agents to use in renting apartments to their own clients. The rental prices of apartments on RDNY.com are exactly the same, to the penny, as the information fed to brokers through Acmelistings.com.
So there is such a thing as a true no fee apartment. Saving the broker's fee represents a very substantial savings up front - when your expenses for rent and security deposit are highest.
After 21 years supplying no broker fee apartments to thousands of users, they must be doing something right.
Is there some legal requirement in New York that rentals must go through a broker? I don't know any other city in the country that you probably will pay a broker fee to rent an apartment. It just seems like the real estate industry dipping their hands into the NYC rental market as a completely unnecessary middle man. I wonder if this is because of New York's history of being majority rentals which, until recently, was fairly unique in the US.
Brokers serve the owner, not the renter. While it may seem like the renter is paying the broker's fee, it's really the owner. Compare the rents of equivalent apartments, one with and one without a broker. You'll find that the one with a broker is "cheaper" by approximately the annualized broker's fee. [0]
[0] My own research, randomly sampling Craigslist postings in NYC.
"Todd founded Rent Tech in 1995 using text pagers to alert clients of new listings. Clients would receive a pager after they signed up for the service, and when a new listing came on the market that fit into their specifications, Rent Tech would send them a page about it. Within two months, the two began to look at how to distribute rental listings on the web, which is where all the company's business now takes place. "
[1] http://www.bizjournals.com/sanfrancisco/stories/1999/09/20/s...
Paying a broker costs roughly a month of rent, so even if the value of your time is $200/hour, you're coming out ahead by doing the work yourself. I've had luck with both pay-to-play aggregators like http://www.rdny.com, as well as blind Google searching. Friends of mine have also done free aggregators like streetyeasy, and one even just showed up to a building and asked about free listings.
This is useful if you want to rent an apartment, not a specific apartment. Many apartments only go through brokers. I don't think that's a good-enough argument to go with one.