News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New steel treatment could enable lighter, stronger, cheap... by kragen on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @05:36AM (#12303402)
This is a really exciting development in materials science. It's surprising and somewhat disheartening that it's taken me ten years to hear about it.

https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2008042982A2/en seems to be the Flash Bainite patent application; if I'm reading this right, he's applied for a patent in the US and Canada, but neither has granted the patent after ten years.

Note that Flash Bainite is a different material than bainite; Flash Bainite contains bainite crystals, but also contains crystals of other phases, including (in the case of AISI 4130) 82.5% martensite. Bainite as such has been known since the 1920s. I'm not completely clear on whether _sammcf is talking about this kind of flash-processed steel in their comments or about some other kind of steel in which bainite plays an important role, though it sounds like they're talking about this stuff.

Putting the Rearden-Steel-like claims he makes in https://www.galtsgulchonline.com/posts/c0a47/hi-my-name-is-g... in context (thanks NamTaf!), the 2080 MPa strength he's claiming there is within a stone's throw of thin music wire, which is far and away higher than that of any other steel. But there's a huge difference in that the 10% elongation at break he's claiming is truly astounding — more like a plastic than a metal. Normal steels break at about 1% elongation, aluminum typically around 3%. Nylon 6,6 is typically around 30%.

The ASM HTPro article http://www.asminternational.org/documents/10192/17082024/Pag... says they got UTS of 1.99 GPa and 10.2% total elongation for "flash processed AISI 4140". I'm not sure yet how much of that elongation is plastic, though judging by the OP's photo of the crumpled thing, maybe most of it.

Bringing those two facts together, it would seem that it's substantially less stiff than ordinary steels, which means that even if all the claims are true, it won't replace them in uses where stiffness matters more than strength — uses like compressive structural members. Furthermore, the strengths discussed so far are ultimate stresses (after plastic deformation is exhausted), not yield stresses (stresses from which the steel will spring back), which may be unspectacular.

In short, it's not a better steel. If these claims are true, it is in effect an entirely new class of material, that just happens to be made out of steel.

Since you reach the Flash Bainite state by quenching, it seems likely that it's metastable and will eventually decay back into a more ordinary steel, but that's true of austenite too — for human applications, metastability is as good as stability if the time to relaxation is measured in billions of years.

There are no comments on this comment yet.