Re:Intel Licenses ARM Technology to Boost Foundry Business
by rayiner on Tuesday August 16, 2016 @11:58PM
(#12302424)
RISC versus CISC was a non-issue even 10 years ago. X86 was never that CISC-y, and x86-64 is straight up a pretty clean architecture, with a memory model that doesn't suck.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Intel Licenses ARM Technology to Boost Foundry Business
by pcwalton on Thursday August 18, 2016 @01:11PM
(#12314364)
> x86-64 is straight up a pretty clean architecture, with a memory model that doesn't suck
I wouldn't go that far. In particular, the encoding of instructions in x86-64 makes zero sense except for backwards compatibility. Since all code is littered with REX prefixes, you have the same i-cache footprint as RISC architectures do without the benefits (die area for decoding, etc.).
If you fixed the instruction encoding, extended the three-address forms of instructions introduced in AVX2 to scalar integer operations, and finally threw away real mode and port mapped I/O, etc., I agree that x86-64 would be pretty nice. I'd be happy to get even one of those improvements, honestly :)
Re:Intel Licenses ARM Technology to Boost Foundry Business
by legulere on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @06:59AM
(#12303710)
The original x86 was pretty unriscy with the registers not being general purpose. The addressing modes to this day are still very CISCy
Re:Intel Licenses ARM Technology to Boost Foundry Business
by fanf2 on Thursday August 18, 2016 @03:38AM
(#12310938)
The addressing modes in x86 are much less CISCy than the VAX or 68040 - no multiple indirections or increments in one instruction. John Mashey explained well the difference http://yarchive.net/comp/risc_definition.html