News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by meowface on Tuesday August 16, 2016 @10:42PM (#12302160)
Assuming Russia's government was involved in the DNC hack (which, despite most of HN repeatedly saying it's just a conspiracy theory or fearmongering or falsely suggesting that the only evidence is Russian IPs or Russian comments, seems quite plausible at this point), they're trying to help elect the candidate who would best serve their interests. Between Hillary and Trump, that's Trump.
Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by saynsedit on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @09:08AM (#12304351)
It's really not that simple.

If there are external groups trying to influence this election, they are not limited to the Russian government. They aren't even limited to governments.

Russia is just the bogeyman du jour of American news media. Many other more capable enemies are completely unreported.

The bogeyman figure is conveniently utilized to spin many stories. E.g. The DNC hack. In this case it's being used to smear Trump's campaign.

The fact is there no substantial evidence Trump is a Russian sympathizer. There is also no evidence that Russia is a Trump sympathizer.

The US has not changed its foreign policy agenda since WW2. There is beautiful continuity from Truman, to Eisenhower, to Kennedy, to Johnson, to Nixon, to Ford, to Carter, to Reagan, to HW Bush, to Clinton, to Bush, to Obama. It's highly unlikely that the next presidential election will have a noticeable effect on our policy towards Russia.

Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by cookiecaper on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @12:11AM (#12302460)
Can you please elucidate on the evidence that Russia was actually behind the DNC leak? I'm genuinely curious. As far as I know, the only evidence we have that Russia is involved is the word of American officials.
Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by sitic on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @12:36AM (#12302540)
Three cybersecurity firms (Crowdstrike, Fidelis Cybersecurity and Mandiant) have said so:

https://www.wired.com/2016/07/heres-know-russia-dnc-hack/

https://www.crowdstrike.com/blog/bears-midst-intrusion-democ...

Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by cookiecaper on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @02:00AM (#12302783)
Thanks, definitely interesting stuff. For the record, Julian Assange has implied that the source was not Russia, but a now-deceased DNC staffer. I guess at some point all we'll have is someone's word for it, either for or against, and we'll each have to make our own judgment on the source's credibility.
Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by adrianm on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @11:11AM (#12305280)
This is the interview in which Julian Assange may or may not imply this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kp7FkLBRpKg
Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by lawnchair_larry on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @06:47AM (#12303638)
Assange implied no such thing, and specifically debunked the meme that he did.
Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by cookiecaper on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @08:55AM (#12304245)
Do you have a link to the specific debunking? I don't think there's really a way to get out of it. I watched multiple interviews with Assange where he brings up Seth Rich unprompted. Of course he proceeds to state that he doesn't comment on sources, but the fact that he's bringing up an unrelated case and saying "it even could have been someone like this guy" is an implication, even if it's followed up by a "denial". Even mainstream outlets were reporting that Assange "suggested" Rich was the source of the leak.

Maybe Rich wasn't the source, but I don't think it can be reasonably denied that Assange was making some kind of implication there. His motives are undefined.

Since this whole discussion is obviously and thoroughly tainted by personal bias (because the information is so fuzzy that it's just about believing the entities that you trust more), I'll just lay out my cards and say that I don't believe that Russian state actors hacked the DNC (though I'm ready to admit it if real evidence is produced, which I understand is probably not possible).

I think it's a cover story because the powers-that-be don't want the average citizen to know how easy it is to compromise the security of very important institutions, whether they be political organizations or major corporations, lest that citizen decide to take up some targets of their own. I believe the same thing happened with the Sony hack that was blamed on North Korea.

It behooves IDS vendors to make people think that nation-states are regularly trying to invade their systems and it's free publicity to come out and corroborate the mainstream narrative, so they play along/feed into it and say "Yeah it was definitely the Russians even though there's no way we'd actually know that since our software wasn't installed until after-the-fact". This is especially blatant with the follow-on firms that just wanted to cash in on the available PR by saying "uh, yeah, we detected that too".

Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by rudolf0 on Thursday August 18, 2016 @03:06PM (#12315428)
>It behooves IDS vendors to make people think that nation-states are regularly trying to invade their systems and it's free publicity to come out and corroborate the mainstream narrative, so they play along/feed into it and say "Yeah it was definitely the Russians even though there's no way we'd actually know that since our software wasn't installed until after-the-fact". This is especially blatant with the follow-on firms that just wanted to cash in on the available PR by saying "uh, yeah, we detected that too".

There is precedent for security vendors falsely claiming that nation states are responsible for some attack when it actually wasn't.

However, in this case top security vendors in direct (and sometimes aggressive competition) with each other are in total agreement, as is every public statement from the intelligence community.

Now, of course, it is in the US government's interest to paint Russia in a bad light, so claims alone aren't enough here. But look at the actual investigative trail ThreatConnect and CrowdStrike presented, and compare it to the past ~5 years of activity from what are almost definitely the same actors, and it's hard to believe they're anything other than a Russia-affiliated group.

Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by lawnchair_larry on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @11:47PM (#12310319)
"though I'm ready to admit it if real evidence is produced, which I understand is probably not possible"

That was settled a long time ago by multiple independent, reputable security companies. It doesn't mean they were the source of the leak though.

Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by cookiecaper on Thursday August 18, 2016 @09:08AM (#12312182)
Yes, I understand multiple security firms have said "It was Russia, trust us." I don't see much corroboration offered up --- they claim it fits an attack profile, which I don't find entirely convincing. That's not evidence, it's testimony. I offered my theory on why they might be motivated to state this absent evidence in the previous comment.

It is fine if you want to believe their narrative. It was constructed to be believable and at this point it's just an independent judgment call on which sources are credible and which scenario seems more plausible (hacking DNC mail server by a nation-state's cyberwarfare apparatus v. internal whistleblower copying data). No hard feelings.

Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by lawnchair_larry on Thursday August 18, 2016 @04:57PM (#12316259)
False Dichotomy. Russia hacked the DNC. Russia may or may not have also leaked the emails. They don't have to be the same event.
Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by mulmen on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @12:37AM (#12302546)
Even if we accept Russian responsibility for the hack how do you know their motive is to sabotage the election? It seems to me that insider knowledge of the party is valuable on its own. Why do you think they are trying to influence the election?

It is likely that Hillary Clinton will be the next president of the United States. Would it not be valuable for Russia to have knowledge of her party? Do you think the CIA would be interested to have inside knowledge of United Russia?

Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by tzs on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @02:37AM (#12302872)
> It seems to me that insider knowledge of the party is valuable on its own.

That kind of information loses most of its value when it is made public. Hence, when an entity with such information releases it, it is usually a safe bet that their goal is to influence public opinion about the party or, if there is information about criminal acts in the information, get someone indicted.

Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by oxide on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @02:26AM (#12302846)
>Why do you think they are trying to influence the election?

because it's an election year?

Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by tropo on Tuesday August 16, 2016 @10:51PM (#12302202)
Hillary approved giving Russia control of 20% of US uranium.

It's obvious that Hillary is better for Russia. I think Putin just likes or admires Trump in an entirely personal way. Having Putin all starstruck could be a good thing.

Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by rrggrr on Tuesday August 16, 2016 @10:58PM (#12302229)
This isn't personal or about admiration. This is about Russian leadership responding to immense economic pressures at home. Buttons have been pushed freezing the assets of Putin supporters, sanctions have been imposed, and Putin's supporter's foreign bank accounts appear to have been exposed. May the Russian leadership have deserved it? Irrelevant. Either way, they appear to be pushing back hard. For you kiddies not around during the Cold War, this so far appears to be light hearted fun by comparison.
Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by whyenot on Tuesday August 16, 2016 @11:05PM (#12302250)
There is no evidence that Clinton was directly involved with this decision. Furthermore, the company involved may have 20% of US uranium production capacity, but it actually only produces about 11% of US uranium.

Please save the Donald Trump talking points for a more appropriate forum.

http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2016/jun/...

Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by nostrademons on Tuesday August 16, 2016 @10:54PM (#12302212)
Putin doesn't like or admire anyone but Putin.
Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by cookiecaper on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @12:06AM (#12302441)
Why characterize Putin as a cartoon villain? I'm sure he is more or less a normal man with peers whom he likes, respects, and admires and peers whom he doesn't. Wild caricatures portend propaganda.
Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by randac on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @09:10AM (#12304366)
Hilarious that this was downvoted, with a cowardly lack of discourse as usual.

Please, continue to assume Putin is a stereotypical cartoon villain. One would think users of a site like HN would have at least passing knowledge of Occam's Razor...

Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by nostrademons on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @02:16PM (#12306922)
I wasn't the one who downvoted, but I've heard someone who has met him speak (in a semi-private, company-internal event), and his exact words were "Putin is scary." This is from someone who is in tight with the current US administration, and who in the same talk mocked Kim Jong-un saying "North Korea has one export - fear. Everything else, they suck at", so it's not like he's afraid of all world leaders.

You don't get to the highest levels of power by being a normal person nor by having other people who you like, respect, and admire, particularly not in a country with a long tradition of autocratic rule. I think that people who are assuming Putin is just another old Joe are projecting their own thought processes onto him, which in a way is admirable - I would love to believe the best in people too - but is at odds with both the culture and history of the country he rules and with the workings of power across all cultures.

Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by riboflava on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @05:32PM (#12308653)
Meeting Putin would scare me just on the basis that as ex-KGB he could snap my neck if he was so inclined. I'm not sure that's enough to really characterize the man, though, at least it's little more than what the people who project average-Joeness have. At least with e.g. Larry Ellison we have many independent reports from those that worked with / under him that we can safely agree it is a mistake to anthropomorphize him.
Re:‘Shadow Brokers’ Leak Raises Question of whether the N.S.... by Relys on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @03:21PM (#12307545)
One does not simply get into that type of position without being an psychological apex predator. In fact, many high functioning sociopaths are attracted to positions of power both in the business and political worlds.