Re:Evolution: The Curious Case of Dogs
by sliverstorm on Tuesday March 30, 2010 @05:01PM
(#1230166)
More importantly, people consider people to be apart from nature. Everyone would agree that dogs have undergone artificial selection- selection controlled by humans. But from a grand-scheme-of-things point of view, humans are just another force of nature, thus it's really just the same old natural selection, survival of the fittest. We just like to think we are something other than nature.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Indeed. The selection dogs have undergone is not, in the final analysis, artificial. The many breeds of dogs are simply seeking out ecological niches in a complex fitness landscape which humans partly define.
I'm not even sure the selection process is all that different from nature's. Is an odd feature in a pet striking a fancy all that different from an odd feature in a mate doing so?
Re:Evolution: The Curious Case of Dogs
by stan_rogers on Wednesday March 31, 2010 @12:37AM
(#1230931)
Indeed it is -- fixing traits (creating homozygosity) in standard breeds involves intense inbreeding, which also makes normally-recessive and harmful traits much more likely to be expressed than in any natural pattern (inbreeding is normally abhorred by nature). Purebred dogs are far more likely to fall victim to cancers, hip displasia and other ailments that would naturally be selected against.