News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A grand unified theory of AI by joe_the_user on Tuesday March 30, 2010 @03:51PM (#1229981)
I agree that fuzzy logic is crap, in the sense that it just involves adding a once-trendy buzzword to ad-hoc approaches.

However, it should be noted that statistical inference is not a necessarily an effective learning approach given that it was created to deal with random variables and the world we are trying to understand has many non-random, orderly aspects.

Humans aren't good at doing the things that statistics is good at but statistics isn't good at doing the things humans are good at. Just as an example, a person can indeed act effectively in uncertain but somewhat ordered environment but virtually no human being can tell you anything like the probability distribution of the events which they deal with in daily life.

So basically, we do indeed need new approach different from both the probabilistic and the pure-logical approaches. But problem is that melding these various existing approaches into something coherent and usable is far more easily said than done. One clear problem with any such system is that the complexity explodes for a formal specification which involves both probability and logical process.

I suggest people call their approach "a general theory" after they do something impressive with it. We're waiting.

Perhaps the intended title of article was "There Ought to Be A General Theory Of AI". That I'd agree with...

There are no comments on this comment yet.