Re:Optimism
by greenshackle on Tuesday August 16, 2016 @03:50PM
(#12300126)
I've read Learned Optimism, Seligman at no point makes the recommendation that overly optimistic people should be less optimistic. He doesn't seem too concerned with accuracy, he just says that optimism will make you happier and more productive, so you should pursue it.
He comes very close to explicitly stating that mild optimistic self-delusion is good, because it will make you happier.
He acknowledges depressive realism, that is, the finding that depressed people make more accurate judgments in certain situations, but doesn't really address it.
The author naturally struggles with pessimism, so his presentation and experiences are framed around forcibly developing more optimistic thought patterns. For the people you describe, perhaps the inverse should be applied (the same article from that perspective would be an interesting read!).
I would say that it's probably generally better for you (and those around you) to err on the side of optimism.