On your second point: it is true that the students are not chained down and kept from self-study, but some might say that school should be a nurturing environment, and not just not_a_jail. These students are learning the value of waiting around without doing much of anything, and are praised for their achievements despite having expended little effort. And I think it would be pretty easy to get the impression that having a 4.0 GPA indicates that you're doing well; but if you're starting the school year far ahead of the evaluation criteria, then it's false feedback.
The word "all" was not used, and inferring it is unduly pedantic. English is not a precise language, which is why there are qualifiers like "all", such as:
1. leaves are green 2. all leaves are green
You used "These students are...". I would not infer that as meaning "All these students are..." and would be surprised if you meant it that way.
As for forcing them to be in slow moving classes, that is not really standing in the way. The student (and I know many who did) can be doing other things at his desk, and certainly a lot of students are doing other things in class :-) Some teachers also allow their highly capable students to spend class time in the school library instead.