News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fake Linus Torvalds' Key Found in the Wild, No More Short... by sleepychu on Tuesday August 16, 2016 @09:50AM (#12297450)
I'm not sure if you're sincere but I don't think emoji would be easier to compare. +Might be less friendly to screen reader users?
Re:Fake Linus Torvalds' Key Found in the Wild, No More Short... by masklinn on Tuesday August 16, 2016 @10:05AM (#12297525)
> I'm not sure if you're sincere but I don't think emoji would be easier to compare.

The point is to leverage human pattern matching so you want short-ish figures with large differences.

Each hex digits is 4 bits, but each emoji is 10 bits, a 128 bits key is 13 emoji which is significantly more eyeballable than 32 hex digits, and chances are you'll notice EGGPLANT being replaced by CAMERA in 13 pictures easier than you'd notice B being replaced by 8 in 32 characters.

Re:Fake Linus Torvalds' Key Found in the Wild, No More Short... by lmm on Wednesday August 17, 2016 @09:36AM (#12304544)
> Each hex digits is 4 bits, but each emoji is 10 bits, a 128 bits key is 13 emoji which is significantly more eyeballable than 32 hex digits, and chances are you'll notice EGGPLANT being replaced by CAMERA in 13 pictures easier than you'd notice B being replaced by 8 in 32 characters.

Compare like with like - what are the two most similar emoji from that set of 2^10 ?

Re:Fake Linus Torvalds' Key Found in the Wild, No More Short... by avisser on Tuesday August 16, 2016 @10:02AM (#12297504)
I hate to say it, but comparing two, long hash values via a screen reader doesn't seem viable for humans, regardless of emoji.

Maybe an auralizer to turn the hash into a short piece of music?

Re:Fake Linus Torvalds' Key Found in the Wild, No More Short... by JulianMorrison on Tuesday August 16, 2016 @10:12AM (#12297555)
See my above example from urbit. They are something a screen reader would clearly read differently for different values, if not comprehensibly.