News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sam Harris: Science can answer moral questions by foldr on Tuesday March 30, 2010 @01:06PM (#1229619)
>This sounds suspiciously like the "Your idea kills children" argument. I call strawman.

Eh? He was just bringing up one of the standard counterexamples to the kind of simplistic utilitarianism that Harris is advocating. I don't know what the "your idea kills children argument" is, but he certainly wasn't making any such argument.

>It would require statistical modeling, and some notion of community-accepted confidence thresholds, to come to a conclusion in a full utilitarian framework.

That's the rub. It doesn't require any of those fancy methods to know that it would be wrong to kill the child. Hence the implausibility of full-on utilitarianism as a reasonable moral philosophy.

(Of course, one can reject full-on utilitarianism without denying that the consequences of our actions for human happiness play a very big role in determining whether they're right or wrong.)

There are no comments on this comment yet.