News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Get the Anti-Startup and Anti-Angel Provisions Struck Fro... by _pius on Tuesday March 30, 2010 @11:37AM (#1229373)
Not so much. The U.S. government has always assumed all of the risk on student lending and was essentially just giving free money to certain private lenders without getting anything in return. It's removing a layer of bureaucracy more than it's a government takeover.

http://www.coffeehousetalks.com/2010/03/landmark-day-for-edu...

Re:Get the Anti-Startup and Anti-Angel Provisions Struck Fro... by waterlesscloud on Tuesday March 30, 2010 @12:16PM (#1229477)
The government was getting plenty in return, an educated populace.

That "bureaucracy" was a private industry. Now it's gone.

Re:Get the Anti-Startup and Anti-Angel Provisions Struck Fro... by lenley on Tuesday March 30, 2010 @09:01PM (#1230642)
What you are talking about really isn't a competitive industry, it is more of "rent-seeking" behavior where private enterprise extracts tax-payer dollars to subsidize their "business."
Re:Get the Anti-Startup and Anti-Angel Provisions Struck Fro... by hga on Tuesday March 30, 2010 @01:18PM (#1229649)
Errr ... is the formerly private bureaucracy going to be replaced by ATMs or the like?

I'm not aware of any claims that this will result in a net loss in loan administration headcount.

Re:Get the Anti-Startup and Anti-Angel Provisions Struck Fro... by lenley on Tuesday March 30, 2010 @02:42PM (#1229840)
Just like the "online tax industry" is fighting to keep the IRS and state tax services from offering direct online tax filing.

I'd likely still use tax-prep software, but I'd like the option to file directly to the irs without an intermediary trying to charge me for services.

I guess that would be another "government takeover." :|

Re:Get the Anti-Startup and Anti-Angel Provisions Struck Fro... by hga on Wednesday March 31, 2010 @07:41PM (#1233357)
That just shuffles who in the private sector gets the data to the IRS, although as long as they're successful they'll ensure the employment of more government workers to oversee the paper to digital capture system.

I'm talking about the necessary people, wherever they are, who then have to process the paper work, deal with random out of band requests, dun people who don't pay up, etc. etc.

That work has to be done somewhere (unless you prefer the model of Medicare with it's low, low overhead and insane level of bogus claims).

Re:Get the Anti-Startup and Anti-Angel Provisions Struck Fro... by jbooth on Tuesday March 30, 2010 @11:05PM (#1230811)
It most likely will - the gov't just hands out the loans, customers come to them, they don't have to market or any of that.

But those jobs marketing a government backed loan shouldn't have existed anyways, no institution was taking a risk to earn that interest, it was a legally created market distortion -- so whatever.

Re:Get the Anti-Startup and Anti-Angel Provisions Struck Fro... by waterlesscloud on Tuesday March 30, 2010 @02:52PM (#1229865)
By that logic you could have any industry run by government employees and not call it a takeover.

Government airline pilots. Government Facebook employees.

No netloss of headcount has nothing to do with it being a takeover or not. It does in fact matter who the employees work for.

Re:Get the Anti-Startup and Anti-Angel Provisions Struck Fro... by jbooth on Tuesday March 30, 2010 @10:31PM (#1230761)
Oh, wah, wah.

Are you seriously arguing the side of a bunch of middle-men who provided no value, saying it's too bad that their industry is going to disappear?

Wow. And I bet you spend the other 364 days of the year talking about how the private sector is so superior through survival of the strongest and all that.