News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sway Finance (YC S16) Automates Accounting for SaaS Compa... by juecd on Monday August 15, 2016 @02:40PM (#12292477)
Hey guys! One of the co-founders of Sway Finance here. We did a ShowHN a couple months ago when we had just built our Slackbot (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11162283) and are excited to now be in YC and building more full-fledged financial products for businesses. Happy to answer any questions here!
Re:Sway Finance (YC S16) Automates Accounting for SaaS Compa... by aidos on Monday August 15, 2016 @05:37PM (#12293672)
I spent the morning complaining at my business partner about how nobody seems to be solving the transaction classification issue. Every site (xero, ynab, pocketsmith etc) seem to think its ok to push all the grunt work off to their customers. I actually spent a couple of hours in the weekend hacking together a script to handle smarter bank transaction classification for me. This couldn't be more timely - will take look and have a play!

Edit to add: also interested in having a system that can project based on previous expenses to help with cash flow forecasting. It's insane that with 3 years of nicely classified data in xero we still have to more or less manually figure out what the next few months look like.

Re:Sway Finance (YC S16) Automates Accounting for SaaS Compa... by hmahncke on Monday August 15, 2016 @04:10PM (#12293035)
This looks great, and automated revenue recognition straight into Quickbooks is a great feature. Do you have a Braintree integration yet, or soon? The integration section suggests not quite yet...
Re:Sway Finance (YC S16) Automates Accounting for SaaS Compa... by juecd on Monday August 15, 2016 @04:47PM (#12293296)
Glad to know auto revenue recognition is useful to you! Not yet, but Braintree is high on our list of integrations to build
Re:Sway Finance (YC S16) Automates Accounting for SaaS Compa... by jasonjei on Monday August 15, 2016 @06:27PM (#12293976)
Is the Quickbooks integration with online or desktop or both?
Re:Sway Finance (YC S16) Automates Accounting for SaaS Compa... by juecd on Tuesday August 16, 2016 @01:17AM (#12295676)
Right now, Quickbooks Online only. We can help switch to QBO if you're open to it!
Re:Sway Finance (YC S16) Automates Accounting for SaaS Compa... by daniel_levine on Monday August 15, 2016 @03:25PM (#12292763)
Big fan of what you all are doing!
Re:Sway Finance (YC S16) Automates Accounting for SaaS Compa... by juecd on Monday August 15, 2016 @03:41PM (#12292868)
Thanks so much!
Re:Sway Finance (YC S16) Automates Accounting for SaaS Compa... by screature2 on Monday August 15, 2016 @05:32PM (#12293640)
One of the big issues I see with accounting/reconciliation systems (automated or even if managed by an external bookkeeper)is that if there isn't good oversight there's a significant cleanup cost usually at a pretty inconvenient time (e.g. just before a due diligence or audit). It's a pretty painful form of infrastructure debt.

How are you guys making sure people remain involved in overseeing and understanding the financials your software's feeding into?

Re:Sway Finance (YC S16) Automates Accounting for SaaS Compa... by juecd on Tuesday August 16, 2016 @01:26AM (#12295708)
Super good point that we've found with our customers who are migrating from outsourced bookkeepers.

We're using our Slackbot as a friendly way for companies to get their financial data, the idea being that if the numbers are accessible/convenient and ones they want to know (revenue, burn rate, bank balances). Then, we can use the same Slackbot to provide other necessary financial details.

We're still working on this, but we think Gusto does a great job of communicating necessary (and not so exciting) info in a way that engages us.

Re:Sway Finance (YC S16) Automates Accounting for SaaS Compa... by tarr11 on Monday August 15, 2016 @05:19PM (#12293540)
So, is it safe to say that you are providing a better rules engine than Quickbooks provides? What about all the other stuff - A/P, A/R, GL, Financial Reports etc?
Re:Sway Finance (YC S16) Automates Accounting for SaaS Compa... by juecd on Tuesday August 16, 2016 @01:21AM (#12295691)
For categorization, we're using ML (which learns over time and isn't rule based like Quickbooks' suggestions, which uses regex).

For the other pieces of bookkeeping, we're using integrations to automatically match invoices/payments (especially disjointed ones, eg invoice through QBO but pay separate via Stripe on client's website). We're also doing stuff like adjusting journal entries programmatically, like payroll accruals. For now, QB is providing the financial reports, we're doing the bookkeeping so their automated reports are accurate!

We're basically doing the services that a bookkeeper would provide on top of a client's Quickbooks software. QB is a tool and we aim to be a service.

Re:Sway Finance (YC S16) Automates Accounting for SaaS Compa... by bcheung on Monday August 15, 2016 @03:26PM (#12292777)
Where does the machine learning come in?

The way article is written it doesn't even hint what the machine learning is being used for.

Re:Sway Finance (YC S16) Automates Accounting for SaaS Compa... by juecd on Monday August 15, 2016 @03:41PM (#12292866)
We're using machine learning (supervised learning) to categorize transactions, generally expenses. We're using our users' past months' books as our training sets of correctly labelled data, so that we can use that data to train is really exciting for us!
Re:Sway Finance (YC S16) Automates Accounting for SaaS Compa... by simonswords82 on Monday August 15, 2016 @04:46PM (#12293292)
How is this better than what say Xero does for reconciliation?
Re:Sway Finance (YC S16) Automates Accounting for SaaS Compa... by juecd on Tuesday August 16, 2016 @01:24AM (#12295697)
Xero and Quickbooks just use basic regex to match transactions, which doesn't make much sense if the transaction category isn't static, eg Amazon. We also learn categories on an aggregate level, so if your bank statement's never seen a transaction from, say Tommy's Tacos, but someone else has, we'll be able to categorize it correctly immediately.
Re:Sway Finance (YC S16) Automates Accounting for SaaS Compa... by simonswords82 on Tuesday August 16, 2016 @03:55AM (#12296092)
Interesting stuff. Good luck with it!