Higher compression ratio = better combustion = more power with less fuel, regardless of turbo.
Higher compression will always mean better fuel efficiency. My moms Mazda CX-5 runs a 13.5 compression ratio and gets 27mpg. The power/efficiency trade off appears when you're talking about turbocharged engines.
Turbos compress air into the combustion chamber, so when you compress compressed air, you get exponentially compressed air. If you don't adjust the compression ratio for the turbo, you're going to get knock. An engine with a 13.5 compression ratio can run perfectly fine on regular gas, but an engine that runs the same ratio and 20 psi of boost with melt itself even on premium gas.
This is a problem for any kind of work vehicle. They almost always have turbos to give them the power to haul their loads with reasonable ease. But this forces the engineers to design the engine with a lower compression ratio, which means at light engine loads, when the turbo isn't doing anything, the engine isn't fulfilling its full potential. It's still compressing air at a low ratio, even though it's not taking in already compressed air. This is where Nissans innovation comes in. The compression ratio will change according to the degree with which the turbo is compressing air. Allowing the engine to run at peak efficiency through the entire range of engine load.
I know where I would put my bets in terms of price, reliability and ease of development.
In any case, an electrically assisted turbo is not a replacement for this. This is a way to have high compression at low loads, such as highway crusing, and ability to lower compression when boost is needed for performance.
This is a common misconception of 'turbo lag'. A modern turbo is actually operating at the low revs too. The boost is there. But a modern turbo engine, especially a diesel, has a very narrow powerband, giving the impression that the turbo isn't active until higher rpms. This isn't real 'turbo lag'. Real 'turbo lag' is the delay caused by the fact that the turbo depends on exhaust pressures, which rise only momentarily after throttle increases. But this problem has largely been solved via mutli-stage turbos, lighter turbo parts, waste gates and the like. Real turbo lag, where it is noticeable, occurs at all rpm ranges.
http://www.caranddriver.com/news/2017-audi-sq7-tdi-diesel-ph...
We have a lot of techniques to improve mpg that increase NOx. If you can figure out how to easily inhibit NOx formation inside the combustion chamber you could be a rich man.
Incedentally this is one way direct gasoline injection can improve economy. The injector sprays directly into the cylinder, and can do so in a way that forms a little donut of air/fuel mix that is insulated from the walls by a layer of air. It is then ignited. The air barrier helps keep combustion temperatures down.
One last thing, really high compression tends to result in a chamber that is very flat and narrow, which can counterproductively cause hotspots and incomplete combustion because the flame front is restricted. This can be fixed with undersquare pistons with longer travel, but that leads to big, low-power, slow-revving engines, like diesels!
http://www.motortrend.com/news/infiniti-prepares-worlds-firs...
There are a few other undesirable things about high-compression.
And I just read your message about knocking. same thing. Nevermind.
Thanks for sharing, that's actually really fascinating.
the patent for anyone interested: https://www.google.com/patents/US4040294
If you want to get really crazy, imagine a WHRU on the manifold in the form of a Rankine cycle where the expander drives a compressor for the air inlet. Like a thermal turbo, if you will, giving you more charge air than NA but with much smaller parasitic power losses than a mechanical turbo.
Variability in something like a combustion chamber is a cool idea, so is variability in the angle of turbo vanes. The issue is how you do it, affordably, and in a way that lasts the way that consumers expect from their cars.
http://www.epi-eng.com/piston_engine_technology/turbocharger...
A better comparison would be variable pitch vanes on jet turbines.
1) lets the engine have high compression AND a turbo. Typically a turbo is run with lower compression, because even today nobody can make an engine run 14:1 with a turbo. Speculating, when you floor it the compression might drop to 8:1 and the turbo kicks in; then when you highway cruise, it runs 14:1 for efficiency.
2) lets the little engine still hit big torque numbers at low speeds. This is most likely if the engine is variable stroke, as longer strokes improve low speed torque.
> The higher the ratio, the more efficiently the engine works, producing better fuel economy and, with the addition of a turbo-charger, more power.
> Traditionally, design engineers had to fix a gasoline engine's combustion compression ratio, essentially deciding whether to go for power or economy.
Everything gets better with higher compression ratio, so where's the compromise? As I understand it, the only reason engine makers don't crank the ratio as high as possible is to avoid knocking.
[0] http://www.reuters.com/article/us-autos-japan-nissan-engine-...