News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by mirimir on Sunday August 14, 2016 @05:02PM (#12287323)
> ... the materials and workmanship are terrible ...

They'll be easy to take down when farmland is needed again :)

Also, one can cut a new door (or loading dock) with just a utility knife ;)

Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by taneq on Sunday August 14, 2016 @09:26PM (#12288108)
Coming from a country where double-brick-and-tile is the gold standard, the concept of building your houses out of what is essentially cardboard tacked onto scaffolding is mindblowing.

On the other hand, when I realised that was the usual construction method in the U.S. it suddenly made sense of a whole bunch of movie moments when people smash into an damage or are thrown through walls.

Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by strictnein on Monday August 15, 2016 @12:02AM (#12288577)
You can't throw people through walls in the US (except for in the movies). Even non-bearing walls are pretty strong and have lots of wood studs in them [0]. http://diy.sndimg.com/content/dam/images/diy/fullset/2011/8/...
Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by taneq on Monday August 15, 2016 @02:30AM (#12289018)
True but at least it's a lot less unbelievable than someone (outside of superpowers or a mecha suit) punching through a brick wall.
Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by GunboatDiplomat on Monday August 15, 2016 @09:43AM (#12290347)
You know that modern construction techniques in the US date back like over 70 years? It's not like the houses fall down. My house was built in like 1960, framed and drywalled, it's here still and perfectly solid. So I'm not sure what your complaint is.
Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by hx87 on Monday August 15, 2016 @12:00PM (#12291278)
"Cardboard tacked onto scaffolding" is plenty strong, especially in an earthquake when brick and tile tend to crumble into dust due to excessive rigidity. Remember, skyscrapers are built using the same "cardboard tacked onto scaffolding", except the scaffolding is steel instead of wood.
Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by hueving on Sunday August 14, 2016 @11:39PM (#12288495)
Gold standard implies that it's high end. High end homes in the US can also have excellent quality as well.
Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by ascorbic on Monday August 15, 2016 @05:31AM (#12289412)
In the UK brick may be gold standard, but basic level would be block work with render or brick facing. Really it's just what builders are used to, and the skills that are available. Bear in mind too that there are a lot of old houses here (by which I mean over 100 years old) and they're not just the high-end ones. There are lots of shoddily-built victorian terraces with single skin brickwork and no foundations, but survivor bias means that somehow they're still standing, even if it is a bit scary when you realise how many are built directly onto bare earth with bricks that fall apart and old mines underneath. They've survived the Luftwaffe and 150 years or so of subsidence, so they're probably fine for another 100 more.

Timber framing is just not the standard, so there are more brickies. The cost isn't that different, otherwise the crappy estates would be built in timber rather than blocks. Likewise plasterboard is skimmed rather than taped, because that's how it's always done and that's what the plasterers are used to, even if the work is more skilled. If the UK does move away from blockwork I'd imagine that as building regs change and the cost trade-offs move it'll switch more to SIPs rather than ever to timber framing.

Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by sevensor on Monday August 15, 2016 @09:52AM (#12290405)
I'd guess this has a lot to do with the availability of resources, too. Timber is much cheaper in the US, so it's not economical to build with sturdier materials. Even some of the larger apartment complexes I've lived in were wood-framed.
Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by bluGill on Monday August 15, 2016 @10:50AM (#12290785)
Brick is not used in England because of cost or strength. Brick is used because historically London has burned down completely leaving many people homeless. Brick ensures that a fire will not spread from one hour to another. When you build a densely packed city it makes perfect sense to use fireproof material at any cost. When your houses are spread farther apart you rely your neighbor's house fire not taking your house down so flammable building materials is much less risk.

In fact brick is NOT always as strong as wood! Brick is stronger under compression, and it feels harder, but under tension brick is much weaker than wood.

Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by taneq on Monday August 15, 2016 @02:30AM (#12289015)
Maybe I should just have said "standard", then. All except for very old, very cheap houses have at least single brick walls and tile or corrugated iron roofing. Nicer ('average' rather than 'high end') houses are double brick and tile.
Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by Spooky23 on Sunday August 14, 2016 @05:13PM (#12287365)
A few years ago in my area, some kid was chased by the local sheriff for driving an ATV on he road.

He drove into some subdivision of $500k homes, wiped out, and the ATV rolled into the side of a house that had no windows. He impact disrupted the glue and be whole side of the house (plywood, sheeting, siding) just fell off!

Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by dpark on Sunday August 14, 2016 @07:23PM (#12287786)
> impact disrupted the glue and be whole side of the house (plywood, sheeting, siding) just fell off!

I don't believe this story can possibly be true. No one glues on plywood, sheeting, or siding. If you glued on the plywood sheathing, you'd have to nail it in place while the glue set anyway. Ditto for the siding. I guess you could glue the sheeting in place, but that's not structural so it wouldn't fall off as you describe here. Gluing the sheeting would probably cost considerably more than just stapling it in place, which is what actually happens.

If this story is true, the builder is doubly stupid, first for building a house this way, and second for spending more money to do so.

Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by Spooky23 on Sunday August 14, 2016 @07:45PM (#12287846)
It was probably a decade ago, so the details may be foggy. But I recall shaking my head at the widely spaced studs that were very visible.
Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by dpark on Sunday August 14, 2016 @10:44PM (#12288345)
Fair enough. I can believe that a poorly built wall fell apart, even if all-glue construction of hard to imagine. There are some shady builders out there.

Just a side note, widely spaced studs isn't necessarily a bad thing. My house is built 24 on center. Leaves more room for insulation on exterior walls, and you don't actually need studs every 16 for strength. I believe there are additional code requirements for houses built with studs spaced 24 on center, though I don't know the details.

Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by menssen on Monday August 15, 2016 @03:24AM (#12289146)
Yep, this is a real thing, and is actually an extremely good idea.

Google "advanced framing".

(Used to work for a tech startup providing services to green construction companies.)

Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by quesera on Monday August 15, 2016 @12:37AM (#12288671)
Residential construction with 2x6 framed walls (for deeper insulation) are often studded 24" on center.
Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by Yhippa on Sunday August 14, 2016 @10:52PM (#12288365)
Can you imagine how many of these things are probably going to be torn down in 20 years? I can still appreciate most houses built in the 70's and 80's due to the fact that they follow a lot of the basic tenets in the article. These things are going to be like those weird commercial building eyesores that were big during the 80's.
Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by sevensor on Monday August 15, 2016 @09:59AM (#12290454)
I've seen some really gross houses from that era. Weird angles, massive blank windowless walls, and I lived in a 1982 condo for a while that had gypcrete floors that were crumbling away to powder under the carpet. A lot of the mistakes of the 70s and 80s have either been torn down already or remedied at the owner's expense.
Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by hx87 on Monday August 15, 2016 @12:04PM (#12291309)
The interiors from the '70s and '80s were far worse than the structures themselves. Whoever though that shag carpeting (i.e. mold food) in bathrooms (i.e. the wettest room in the house) was a great idea?
Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by sevensor on Monday August 15, 2016 @12:48PM (#12291605)
Ugh! That reminds me -- the condo with gypcrete floors had carpeted bathrooms.

Anyhow, I've visited a McMansion or two, and I think in a few years we're all going to shudder at how badly dated the interiors are too. But which features age badly and which ones still seem charming after the fact remains to be seen. Granite countertops? Stainless steel appliances? Mammoth bathtubs? Closets you could sleep a family in? Two sinks in the bathroom?

Re:What Makes a McMansion Bad Architecture? by hx87 on Monday August 15, 2016 @01:40PM (#12292000)
All of those features are here to stay, especially the latter three since they're mostly a function of having lots of space. One feature that will date badly is the bland white/beige/peace/flesh/etc paint palette; in a effort not to offend anyone, it ends up pleasing no one. How about some, blue, red, and green, as so many gorgeous 19th century houses had?