Re:From first principles: Why I bet on Scala.js
by premium-concern on Saturday August 13, 2016 @04:29PM
(#12282975)
Well, Scala.js went from not existing to rock solid in 3 years. The various Haskell-to-JS efforts existed much longer, but none have the support, completeness and maturity of Scala.js.
Re:From first principles: Why I bet on Scala.js
by willtim on Sunday August 14, 2016 @04:17AM
(#12284749)
That is down to who has the most funding. Javascript itself has even more "support, completeness and maturity" than Scalajs. But obviously that's not the deciding factor.
Re:From first principles: Why I bet on Scala.js
by premium-concern on Sunday August 14, 2016 @07:36AM
(#12285193)
Scala.js was largely done by a single student on top of his other university duties.
I think it's mostly down to determination. Some things are hard, but need to be done.
Haskell people just seem to give up more easily - see all the half-working projects. Nobody finishes stuff, the next dev just starts his own new project, and abandons it later.
Scala.js handily beats JavaScript in terms of IDE support and tooling
Re:From first principles: Why I bet on Scala.js
by willtim on Sunday August 14, 2016 @12:35PM
(#12286225)
A quick Google suggests Scalajs has had developers paid to work on it (EPFL lab and Lightbend): http://scala-lang.org/blog/2016/03/14/announcing-the-scala-c...
The Haskell community has achieved great things even though most contributions are done in people's spare time. That is determination.
Re:From first principles: Why I bet on Scala.js
by premium-concern on Monday August 15, 2016 @04:34AM
(#12289299)
That's nonsense. I think it's great that outside contributions (like allowing the use of the Scala's CI infrastructure) are valued, but the actual commits show a clear picture.
There is no determination in failing to get anything done and doing NIH for a decade.
I could give a recap of Haskell development that's happened while Scala.js has been developed to debunk this silly accusation, but it wouldn't change your mind.