Re:Judge: Gene Patents Are Invalid
by carbocation on Tuesday March 30, 2010 @03:35AM
(#1228617)
The judge also slams them for trying to patent the scientific method (see either page 152 or 153, if I remember correctly).
PDF: http://www.aclu.org/files/assets/2010-3-29-AMPvUSPTO-Opinion...
According to my reading of the case, the company didn't invent a breast cancer procedure. Instead, they found a gene that has some involvement in breast cancer and tried to claim suppressing said gene. They lost because their patent didn't disclose or claim anything relevant to suppressing said gene.
IFRC, the judge said that they didn't invent anything, which they pretty much conceded. Since you can't patent discoveries, only uses of discoveries to do something, they lost.