News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by rbanffy on Saturday August 13, 2016 @06:01AM (#12280931)
> he cited Soviet central economic planning as an extreme example of the sort of danger to which he refers.

Any intellectualism that's divorced from reality and impervious to critique and verification does not deserve to be called intellectualism. It's ideology. There's nothing preventing you from making 5 year plans, as long as you adjust them continuously enough. The word to best describe the Soviet "intellectuals" you mentioned would be "ideologue". A less polite way would be "a sold-out who sells credibility to a government that pays for it".

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by jerf on Saturday August 13, 2016 @10:20AM (#12281592)
"Any intellectualism that's divorced from reality and impervious to critique and verification does not deserve to be called intellectualism."

True, but that's a definitional debate. I would be happy to see the huge pile of ideology today masquerading as academia correctly renamed, but before that can happen it seems a lot of people (in the general sense, not targeting this statement at any individual) must be introduced to the idea that there are a lot of things currently labeled "academic" that are just ideology.

It's hard because you have to separate it on a case-by-case basis. I'm broadly unimpressed by most of what is called sociology but Jonathon Haidt particularly impresses me, for instance. I'm sure there are others who would impress me if I took the time to learn. But the field as a whole seem to have a gestalt consensus that strikes me as quite resistant to falsification.

Re:Why professors, pundits, and policy wonks misunderstand t... by rbanffy on Saturday August 13, 2016 @01:40PM (#12282290)
It's very hard to falsify something when you can't run experiments and the number of samples is very limited and the subject of your study changes all the time. Even something supposedly more grounded like Economics suffers from both humans that are not perfectly rational and from "theories" that are nothing more than propaganda (think Mises)