What the fork shows is that they were willing, at least once, to launch a big effort to save one large faulty contract and its investors, in the still relatively early history of the blockchain.
It seems ridiculous to think that Ethereum as a platform will have a serious system of regulation. And that's part of why this kind of one-off special case fork is so problematic.
Let me offer some data points:
https://www.reddit.com/r/ethereum/comments/4vlk4j/consensys_...
Projects confirmed on ETH: Ethereum Foundation, Digix, Maker, Colony, AKASHA, ROULΞTH, Plutus, REIDAO, vDice, SingularDTV, Braveno, Etheropt, otlw, Etherdelta, Swarm, Gnosis, Augur, Velocity, FreeMyVunk, RealityKeys, Golem, EOL, ConsenSys, ICONOMI, EthSlurp, Decibel.LIVE, cPay, Rex, DinarDirham, Embark, Dindle (Decentralised eBook Market), uPort
Projects confirmed on ETC: Stampery, Daemon Dark Market
Which makes it seem a bit disingenuous to claim that Ethereum contracts are now "just like" ordinary contracts, or that Ethereum is a "regulated platform."
The hard fork looks like a slightly panicked reaction to a rather extreme situation that threatened to undermine the platform in its very early days.
I don't agree that "nobody in their right mind" would trust Ethereum now and we'll see how that plays out.
> "Fiat smart contracts"
Isn't this just a synonym for "regular contract"?
As for ETH putting regulation in place makes more sense. What you get is "regulated smart contracts" environment. "Fiat smart contracts" if you will. The real question then turns into: How is the regulatory authority governed? Is it a participatory democracy? A representative democracy? A dictatorship?
That's not to say that there's no need platform for unregulated smart contracts as well.