The CEO was the founder of Nanosolar, which printed solar cells and went bust because, although the process worked, it wasn't cheaper. The investors in Diamond Foundry are the usual suspects - Zynga's founder, Sun Microsystem's founder, Facebook's co-founder, a former eBay CEO, etc. They even have an actor, for coolness. An endorsement by Leonardo DiCaprio: “I’m proud to invest in Diamond Foundry Inc.– reducing the human and environmental toll of the diamond industry by sustainably cultivating diamonds without the destructive use of mining.” It's a classic startup story.
They claim to be "0.001% Rare"; this reflects their market share, like a microbrewery. Their big problem seems to be distribution. Only five small jewelers handle their product. De Beers punishes jewelers who do things they don't like by excluding them from "sights" where jewelers can buy diamonds at wholesale prices. This makes it hard for competitors to get access to retail outlets.
... just to piss in the cornflakes of the DeBeers cartel.
This is not a war they can win.
Global Witness, the organisation who pushed for the 'blood diamonds' campaign, disavowed it in 2011, because the scheme did not actually provide effective guarantees that the diamonds sold were not blood diamonds.
Others have pointed out the strange absence of any 'blood emeralds' scheme, even though they are often sourced from the same corrupt organisations and countries. But the fact that natural emeralds are much rarer than diamonds means that no-one needs to artifically limit their supply...
It makes me wonder if the synthetic guys have a leg to stand on regarding the ecological footprint of pit mining versus lab grown, or if it's about the same. Maybe they could cook up their own marketing label and stop trying to hide what they're doing.