News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:World Elephant Day: Why It Matters by TeMPOraL on Friday August 12, 2016 @04:00PM (#12278357)
> All the other things don't directly cause suffering of an intelligent species

What? All those things directly cause suffering of an intelligent species. That's why people tried to ban them.

> You know what, instead of banning cannibalism, we should regulate human meat consumption.

Cannibalism isn't an issue not because it's banned, but because... well... people generally aren't doing that. There is no demand for human meat.

It seems that the biggest problems with bans happen when a good so heavily demand-driven it becomes profitable for organized crime to form around a black market for that good.

> Let's not. It's cruel, economically and ecologically not feasible.

I think the right question to ask is - is it crueler / environmentally bad than poaching?

> Also this would wouldn't stop poaching in the wild.

It would - if you'd combine verifiable, legally obtainable source with harsh punishment for poachers.

Re:World Elephant Day: Why It Matters by adamnemecek on Friday August 12, 2016 @04:07PM (#12278403)
> What? All those things directly cause suffering of an intelligent species. That's why people tried to ban them

People in general dislike suffering. If it was causing them suffering, they wouldn't be doing those things. Also you are kind of splitting hairs. In a country with legalized alcohol, no one is hurt from manufacturing of alcohol (just manufacturing, let's ignore consumption).

> Cannibalism isn't an issue not because it's banned, but because... well... people generally aren't doing that. There is no demand for human meat.

Is that the only reason?

> I think the right question to ask is - is it crueler / environmentally bad than poaching?

Misleading question. You are comparing farming with poaching when the third option is little to no poaching, just like in the 20 years before 2008.

> verifiable, legally obtainable source

Please elaborate.

Re:World Elephant Day: Why It Matters by gohrt on Saturday August 13, 2016 @02:23AM (#12280509)
> It would - if you'd combine verifiable, legally obtainable source with harsh punishment for poachers.

If that worked, we could skip the "obtainable source" and just do harsh punishment for poachers, for an even better result.

Re:World Elephant Day: Why It Matters by TeMPOraL on Saturday August 13, 2016 @04:23AM (#12280745)
No, we couldn't - the point is shifting demand to legitimate sources and pricing poachers out, not playing whack-a-mole with them.