News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Breast cancer genes ruled unpatentable (by NY district co... by mmastrac on Monday March 29, 2010 @07:13PM (#1227811)
Ruling available here: http://www.aclu.org/files/assets/2010-3-29-AMPvUSPTO-Opinion...

The interesting bits start on page 96 (have to type this in by hand from the PDF):

"The rule that the discovery of a law of nature cannot be patented rests [...] they are not the kind of discovery that the status was enacted to protect."

Re:Breast cancer genes ruled unpatentable (by NY district co... by _delirium on Monday March 29, 2010 @08:58PM (#1228013)
It seems reasonable to me. There's a gray area between "discovery" and "invention", but finding a gene seems more like discovering something new about how gravity works. If a physicist did that, they couldn't get a blanket patent on the very idea of a device that took advantage of that gravitational feature.

Where it does get trickier is that it seems that said physicist might be able to patent a particular kind of new machine that took advantage of their discovery, and analogously, someone might be able to patent a particular kind of chemical or device that uses this gene.

Re:Breast cancer genes ruled unpatentable (by NY district co... by lutorm on Monday March 29, 2010 @09:38PM (#1228080)
I don't think it's so tricky, and I think that's exactly what the ACLU said: that you can patent therapies or drugs or whatever that work on that gene, but you can't patent the gene itself.