Re:Breast cancer genes ruled unpatentable (by NY district co...
by _delirium on Monday March 29, 2010 @08:58PM
(#1228013)
It seems reasonable to me. There's a gray area between "discovery" and "invention", but finding a gene seems more like discovering something new about how gravity works. If a physicist did that, they couldn't get a blanket patent on the very idea of a device that took advantage of that gravitational feature.
Where it does get trickier is that it seems that said physicist might be able to patent a particular kind of new machine that took advantage of their discovery, and analogously, someone might be able to patent a particular kind of chemical or device that uses this gene.
Re:Breast cancer genes ruled unpatentable (by NY district co...
by lutorm on Monday March 29, 2010 @09:38PM
(#1228080)
I don't think it's so tricky, and I think that's exactly what the ACLU said: that you can patent therapies or drugs or whatever that work on that gene, but you can't patent the gene itself.
The interesting bits start on page 96 (have to type this in by hand from the PDF):
"The rule that the discovery of a law of nature cannot be patented rests [...] they are not the kind of discovery that the status was enacted to protect."