Re:GNU founder Stallman: ‘Open source is not free software’
by catdog on Thursday August 11, 2016 @06:14PM
(#12272014)
I think the GPL can be seen as a clever law hack (in the sense of creatively using something in ways not originally intended). In this case not to enforce restrictions in usage but to actually enforce the opposite.
Re:GNU founder Stallman: ‘Open source is not free software’
by jessaustin on Thursday August 11, 2016 @03:14PM
(#12270879)
"Strategy" is not an significant concept for free software critics like the parent. They have seen this argument, but they are strictly first-order thinkers so it hasn't registered for them.
Your argument is more or less correct, but it's a feature, even as seen by free software advocates. Not really a fallacy.
Compare it to the argument for gender quotas. A fair criticism, along similar lines, is that if you really do believe in equal rights and fair chances then you shouldn't argue for gender quotas, as they are, in fact directly opposed to equal rights.
In both cases the argument fails because it conflates interim strategies, designed as bootstraping mechanisms, as an application of the principles it's supposed to further.