News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GNU founder Stallman: ‘Open source is not free software’ by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday August 11, 2016 @09:17AM (#12267936)
Stallman's view is even more developer-centric.

Who cares about source code? Not most users.

If the aim was to make software that's easily user-modifiable - user-modifiable, not developer-modifiable - free software has been a complete failure.

There's certainly a net benefit in distributing software with free access to source code so it can be modified by experienced developers.

But that has never been Stallman's stated aim. If Stallman and the FSF really cared about users - not developers - they'd have spent more time creating software systems that were user-editable.

In fact the industry, including Stallman, has stampeded in the opposite direction.

It's harder for ordinary users to make modifiable software now than it's ever been in the past. We no longer have HyperCard, VB and VBA are dying arts, and the insides of all operating systems - including Linux - are absolutely horrible environments for non-developers to work in. We don't even have BASIC or those make-your-own game systems we had in the 8-bit days.

Those were bare minimum systems. Has it really been impossible to invent something better for more than 30 years?

No one knows. But for all the rhetoric, the question interests Stallman as little as it interests the rest of the industry.

Re:GNU founder Stallman: ‘Open source is not free software’ by bad_user on Thursday August 11, 2016 @09:36AM (#12268083)
> Who cares about source code? Not most users.

That's not correct. People care about their problems being solved. Hence they care about the source code implicitly.

When my car is broken or needs an oil change, I don't do it myself, I take it into a car repair shop and I like the freedom to go to any car repair shop I want, because those folks from our local Peugeot representative charge an arm and a leg.

That's how freedom works dude ;-)

Re:GNU founder Stallman: ‘Open source is not free software’ by oldmanjay on Thursday August 11, 2016 @10:11AM (#12268346)
Your point relies on a significant number of users caring about such things, but empirically, they just don't. No number of car analogies will make GPL-style software freedom meaningful for the vast majority of people.
Re:GNU founder Stallman: ‘Open source is not free software’ by devishard on Thursday August 11, 2016 @05:03PM (#12271513)
Do you remember when Internet Explorer was the only kid on the block, and then Firefox came out and was a breath of fresh air? I know a lot of non-programmers who cared about that, and that's a direct result of the ability for anyone to modify software. Remember that Firefox was based on Netscape, which had previously been knocked out of existence by IE. The difference between Netscape and Firefox was freedom to distribute modifications, and that made a lot of difference to a lot of users.
Re:GNU founder Stallman: ‘Open source is not free software’ by gonvaled on Thursday August 11, 2016 @01:25PM (#12270082)
Users definitely care about not being tied to a certain provider.
Re:GNU founder Stallman: ‘Open source is not free software’ by davexunit on Thursday August 11, 2016 @09:24AM (#12267994)
The GNU project boasts some of the most hackable software ever made. GNU Emacs is the most notable. RMS has been an advocate for languages like Lisp over languages like C because programs written in Lisp, like Emacs, are user extensible.
Re:GNU founder Stallman: ‘Open source is not free software’ by protomyth on Thursday August 11, 2016 @09:37AM (#12268088)
> The GNU project boasts some of the most hackable software ever made. GNU Emacs is the most notable.

Politics sometimes stops the hackablity https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8861360

Re:GNU founder Stallman: ‘Open source is not free software’ by GFK_of_xmaspast on Thursday August 11, 2016 @09:42AM (#12268119)
If that were the case, how does that explain the "plugins for gcc" issue.
Re:GNU founder Stallman: ‘Open source is not free software’ by nickpsecurity on Thursday August 11, 2016 @11:51AM (#12269233)
"Who cares about source code? Not most users."

I agree with bad_user that they care implicitly. They care when Oracle is gouging them at $40-70k when it could be free to $5k. They didn't like Microsoft taking away their start button, which was easy to bring back for FOSS GUI. Many didn't want to spend much on a computer for basic tasks, which Linix distros on Netbooks helped with. Many wanted more or specific applications for their smartphones, which Android lets you have. Many want their OS to not spy on them like Windows 10 does, which requires being able to inspect or modify it.

So, they care. They just rarely see it put in terms they understand. Whenever I do, they always support the alternative even if they won't buy it occasionally due usually to backward compatibility with locked-in stuff (eg Office, Oracle, SAP) Stallman warned about or just their personal preference (eg iPhone over Android).

"If the aim was to make software that's easily user-modifiable - user-modifiable, not developer-modifiable - free software has been a complete failure."

Yeah, that's true. It also, as you note later, hasn't been easily developer-modifiable either with how they write it. One of reasons for LLVM's existence was how much of a pain it was to work with GCC. And all kinds of people want to improve FOSS software but few can or do. The dream and reality are quite different.

Re:GNU founder Stallman: ‘Open source is not free software’ by catdog on Thursday August 11, 2016 @05:01PM (#12271505)
> Who cares about source code? Not most users.

Mot users probably don't know that it's something to care about.

> There's certainly a net benefit in distributing software with free access to source code so it can be modified by experienced developers.

Even if a user is unable to do modifications himself, there is still a huge indirect benefit because he can use modifications others make or he may hire somebody to do modifications.

> But that has never been Stallman's stated aim. If Stallman and the FSF really cared about users - not developers - they'd have spent more time creating software systems that were user-editable.

The stated aim is to make it possible to freely share and modify software, not to make everyone an expert in the field. Sure educating people and lowering the barrier at some points would perfectly align with the goal of free software but it's still something different.

> Those were bare minimum systems. Has it really been impossible to invent something better for more than 30 years?

Also a lot less capable systems.