Re:GNU founder Stallman: ‘Open source is not free software’
by prodigal_erik on Thursday August 11, 2016 @12:21PM
(#12269511)
The usual reductio ad absurdum is: In another world, you are allowed to sell yourself into slavery. In this one, you are not. How can the world containing slaves be the one that's more free?
Re:GNU founder Stallman: ‘Open source is not free software’
by Nomentatus on Thursday August 11, 2016 @10:52PM
(#12273141)
In other words, the code is free until it is added to, becomes proprietary and - if a network effect adheres - then that proprietary version can dominate and in effect extinguish the public domain version. Certainly extinguish nearly all its value. The once-again-enslaved code lives and thrives, the freeman code perishes, or nearly so. That's a good argument, but the whole problem is created by an IP system that perverts the concept behind copyright. Paintings don't prevent other paintings from competing, code with a network effect or lock in does. Copyright should either never have been applied to code, or be for a very short period. Let's say, four years or eight years. Then BSDL code going proprietary isn't a threat, it's a bonus: more free code soon enough.
Stallman wants, real hard, for this restriction of freedoms to be viewed as somehow "more free", and is fairly hardline about it. I wish he'd stop using freedom as his motivator and just talk about ensuring information access, which is really what his goal is.