Re:The Great Productivity Puzzle
by vasilipupkin on Thursday August 11, 2016 @02:09PM
(#12270434)
I am talking about better not in some sort of philosophical sense, but in terms of GDP and GDP per capita
Even then you haven't proven your point: might not GDP per capita go up if the population goes down?
Re:The Great Productivity Puzzle
by vasilipupkin on Thursday August 11, 2016 @03:44PM
(#12271076)
GDP per capita for those remaining indivuduals would only go up if those who disappeard were somehow destroying GDP per capita for those who remained. How is that possible in any reasonable state of the world ? As long as those who disappeared where on average non zero marginal product, then their disappearance would lower GDP per capita for the remaining ones
Why should the US not have many fewer people and why couldn't that be better? There's nothing magical about 315 million people. A much smaller population would be better for ecosystems, global warming, etc. I'd demand the proviso that the population shouldn't be decimated overnight and that the age distribution can't be too skewed (too many youth or too many old). But barring that, I don't see why some lower population (even tenfold fewer) couldn't be "better".