Re:Hellwig Will Appeal VMware Ruling After Evidentiary Set B...
by gknoy on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @03:07PM
(#12257012)
I find it amazing that the law prohibits a judge from saying, "The statute of limitations period means that this cannot be valid," and throw the case out, but rather requires one of the lawyers to do so.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Hellwig Will Appeal VMware Ruling After Evidentiary Set B...
by Tomte on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @03:14PM
(#12257057)
Yes, it sounds strange.
I've just looked up in a legal commentary, and it isn't as clear-cut as my acquaintance told it to me.
Baumbach/Lauterbach/Hartmann say that the judge may broach the issue if the defense has expressed doubts about the time-line of actions, but that it must not reach the level of advice.
Other commentaries say that the judge must not broach the issue.
And there is even a cool minority opinion in NJW (Schneider), saying that the declining quality of jurists' training may lead to the judge having to protect the client from his own lawyer. ;-)
Re:Hellwig Will Appeal VMware Ruling After Evidentiary Set B...
by ethbro on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @03:23PM
(#12264197)
It makes some sense as judge as arbiter and interpreter of law, no? If a judge were to say "You should argue this" then the expectation that he or she would be predisposed to finding that a valid claim would be pretty apparent.
I can see examples where this would lead to slippery slopes in both the defendant's and plaintiff's favors.