And the higher the ranking, the higher the potential revenue in the future.
Remember: you can never have too much traffic. If you do, cope with it, it's only going to help you (unless you have 0 business sense).
(also there are a few services kicking around that try to solve these problems)
Kids tend to get allowances and spending money as gifts for birthdays, Christmas, Easter, etc. in the UK at least.
Half a million 15-year-olds watch the clip, and none of them immediately buy the product. But it's fair to assume at least 10% of the girls remember the brand name, and the remaining 90% will remember that for custom designed shoes they should go with "whatever the brand was that got recommended by shinyrainbowprincess". That's a lot of brand recognition.
But let's look at it from a cost perspective for a moment. I'm almost entirely sure that she got paid less than $10.000 for the advertisement. Probably way less, but what do I know? Suppose they did pay $10.000, then they only need to sell an extra 100 shoes or so to break even (assuming they have a healthy profit margin). That's peanuts, really.
So even if there are no direct conversions, and the only benefit is word of mouth or brand recognition the shoe shop still got a deal of a lifetime. Half a million people, that's half the circulation of the New York Times! And most people spend only 10 or so minutes on the paper, which is the same as the length of the advertisement.
I think they timed this competition very well because isn't prom coming up very soon? How many of these girls that didn't buy their design are going to be pestering their parents to get their custom shoe in time for prom? What about next year?
There's a hidden lesson in this story. 22 Michaels learned this lesson the hard way. The lesson is simple: not all traffic is created equal. It turns out that Youtube views, Youtube comments, Youtube ranking, Facebook shares, and pageviews don't mean much. They're vanity metrics - nice to look at but lacking content.
The only thing that matters is sales. Find traffic sources that generate sales and pour money into the channels the most sales dollars per advertising dollar.